Employer Steps When State & Federal Forms Expire (DOL, USCIS, Tax, etc.)

When federal agency forms (such as DOL or USCIS paperwork) pass their printed expiration date, employers can typically continue using the current version unless a brand-new edition have been officially released or check USCIS I-9 Central for direct updates.

Understanding Expiration Dates

  • OMB Control Dates: The printed date represents approval from the Office of Management and Budget for data collection, not a strict legal cutoff for the document content itself.
  • Grace Periods: Agencies often extend past expiration dates or roll them over while review processes happen behind the scenes.
  • Active Validation: Always check the issuing government agency website to see if a replacement version is actively required for new filings.

Best Practices for Compliance

  • Keep Using Current Stock: Continue using the existing form safely if no replacement has been published yet.
  • Swap When Released: Update internal HR portals and software systems immediately once a newer edition is formally issued.
  • Do Not Retroactively Fix: You generally do not need to redo past correctly filled forms just because a new version was later released.

Current FMLA Website:

https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/fmla/forms

Steps Employers Should Take

1. Identify Expired Forms
The first step is to conduct a thorough review of all employment forms currently in use. This includes:

  • W-4 Forms: Federal Employee’s Withholding Certificate
  • I-9 Forms: Employment Eligibility Verification
  • State-Specific Forms: Varies by state, including tax withholding forms and labor law posters.

2. Stay Informed on Updates
Employers should regularly check for updates from relevant federal and state agencies. This can be done by:

  • Subscribing to newsletters from the IRS, Department of Labor, and state labor departments.
  • Visiting official websites for announcements regarding form changes or expirations.

3. Replace Expired Forms
Once expired forms are identified, employers should:

  • Obtain Updated Forms: Download the latest versions from official government websites.
  • Communicate Changes: Inform employees about the need to complete new forms, emphasizing the importance of compliance.

4. Implement a Compliance System
To prevent future issues with expired forms, employers should establish a compliance system that includes:

  • Regular Audits: Schedule periodic reviews of employment forms to ensure they are current.
  • Tracking System: Use a digital or physical tracking system to monitor the expiration dates of forms.

5. Train HR Staff
Ensure that human resources personnel are well-informed about the importance of using current forms. Training should cover:

  • The implications of using expired forms.
  • Procedures for updating forms and communicating changes to employees.

6. Maintain Employee Records
Employers should keep accurate records of all employment forms, including:

  • Completed Forms: Store both current and expired forms for reference.
  • Documentation of Updates: Maintain a log of when forms were updated and distributed to employees.

7. Address non-compliance
If an employer inadvertently uses expired forms, they should:

  • Assess the Situation: Determine the extent of non-compliance and any potential penalties.
  • Correct the Issue: Promptly replace expired forms and ensure all employees complete the new versions.
  • Consult Legal Counsel: If necessary, seek legal advice to navigate potential repercussions.

Proactive audits and awareness of expiration dates are necessary to remain legally compliant.  In the many audits I have conducted, expired forms continue to be an issue.  I am happy to answer any questions related to compliance, process and correcting.

7 Reasons to Implement Stay Interviews in Your Organization

What is a stay interview?  “A stay interview is a structured discussion a leader conducts with an individual employee to learn specific actions the leader can take strengthen the employee’s engagement and retention with the organization.”[i]  What is the value of the stay interview?  The organization hears directly from the employee in a one-on-one discussion (not related to performance), with any issues, concerns and opportunities for leadership improvement.  This provides us as leaders with the opportunity to engage, communicate and retain the workforce.  The stay interviews should be conducted by the leader of the organization, with HR’s support.  I have effectively used stay interviews.

Below are the thoughts on implementing stay interviews:

  1. Start at the Top:  The leader at the top of the organization should set the tone for the organization and conduct stay interviews with their direct reports.  The process should cascade down throughout the rest of the organization to front-line supervisors and employees.  Employees at every level should take part in a stay interview, to ensure an effective and successful process.
  2. In Person: Stay interviews should not be conducted over the phone or via a video conferencing system, if possible.  Remote workers should have the opportunity to sit one-on-one with their supervisor and have a discussion. 
  3. Expectations of the Stay Interview:  Ensure the employee understands the reason for the stay interview and how these interviews will focus on areas that the manager can influence.  Not all of us can change company policy, mission statements and strategic goals.  However, if a trend in these interviews is consistent, we might have more say in strategic objectives.
  4. Schedule Time: “Most stay interviews take 20 minutes or less to conduct, but some will carry on longer. Leaders should consider telling employees to allow 20 minutes for their meeting, but even then, leaders should allow thirty minutes on their calendars.”[ii]  Treat the employee as you want to be treated during the stay interview.
  5. Leave Performance Out of It: There is a time and place to discuss performance expectations.  Stay interviews should remain focused on engagement, retention feedback, communication and concerns.  Scripted open-ended questions are necessary.
  6. No Advanced Questions: This can limit the conversation to a list of memorized demands and responses.  Open-ended discussion with note taking, listening and probing for additional information will add tremendous value to the stay interview.
  7. Opening Script: The pre-drafted script is a great way to open the meeting.  This will provide additional information to the employee on what the process will look like and the direction of the interview.  The messages will be consistent throughout the organization.

The Why of Stay Interviews:

  • “Employees hear directly from their supervisor that they care and want them to stay and grow with the company. 
  • Supervisors further accept retention and engagement within their sphere of responsibility. 
  • Employees are more likely to accept responsibility for staying. 
  • Stay interviews build trust.”[iii]

Stay Interview Draft Template:
To open the stay interview, a manager may use the following (or similar) statements:

  • I would like to talk with you about the reasons you stay with ____, so I understand what I might be able to do to make this a great place to work.
  • I’d like to have an informal talk with you to find out how the job is going, how the job will change, so I can do my best to support you as your manager, particularly with issues within my control. 
  • I will be taking notes throughout our discussion and might ask you to repeat yourself if I do not capture everything.
  • Do you have any questions before we get started?

Review Job Description and Changing Expectations

  • These are the current changes to the job description
  • These will be the changes to the position and current expectations/accountabilities
  • Discuss the reporting structure
  • Communication expectations
  • System reporting expectations
  • Do you have any questions or concerns?

Questions
The following are questions you may ask during a stay interview. You should have several open-ended questions on hand. It’s important to listen and gather ideas from the employee about how you and your organization can retain him or her.

  • Tell me specifically, what factors cause you to enjoy your current job and work situation (including people, job, rewards, job content, coworkers, management etc.), and as a result, they contribute to your staying at our firm as long as you have?
  • What gets your excited to come to work here every day?
  • What do you look forward to when you come to work each day?
  • What do you like most or least about working here?
  • What keeps you working here?
  • If you could change something about your job, what would that be?
  • What would make your job more satisfying?
  • How do you like to be recognized?
  • What talents are not being used in your current role?
  • What would you like to learn here?
  • What motivates (or demotivates) you?
  • What can I do to best support you?
  • What can I do more of or less of as your manager?
  • What can we be doing differently as a management team?  Communication, meetings, etc.
  •  If you “managed yourself,” what would you do differently (in relation to managing “you”), that I, as your current manager, don’t currently do?
  • What might tempt you to leave?

Stay Interview Template
We would appreciate you taking 8-10 minutes to answer the following questions as honestly as possible. Your individual responses are treated as confidential and will not become part of your personnel file. We believe that the information is of vital importance and will assist in analyzing and improving our employee satisfaction and culture. Thank you for your participation!

Employee Name (Last, First, & Middle)Employee ID NumberDate of Hire
   
Job TitleSupervisor/Manager NameDepartment
   
Select the top 3 reasons you remain in your position. 
☐ Type of Work
☐ Compensation
☐ Benefits
☐ Company Culture
☐ Business/Product Direction ☐ Quality of Supervision
☐ Support from Team
Members
☐ Work-Life Balance
☐ Career Advancement
Opportunity
☐ Other: __________________
 
      

What do you think of your supervision in regard to the following?

 ExcellentGoodFairNeeds Improvement
Demonstrates fair and equal treatment
Comments
Provides recognition on the job
Comments
Encourages cooperation and teamwork
Comments
Requests feedback and listens to suggestions
Comments

How would you rate the following in relation to your job?

 ExcellentGoodFairNeeds Improvement
Collaboration within your department
Comments
Collaboration with other departments
Comments
Communication in your department
Comments
Communication within the company as a whole
Comments
Communication between you and your manager
Comments
Morale in your department
Comments
Job satisfaction
Comments
Training opportunities
Comments
Growth potential
Comments

What do you think makes us standout as a good place to work?

 
 
 
 

What are the challenges with working here? Any suggestions for improvements?

 
 
 
 

What keeps you working here? What do you most look forward to coming into work each day?

 
 
 
 

If you could change something about your job to make it more satisfying, what would that be?

 
 
 
 

What would you like to learn here? What can the company do to best support you?

 
 
 
 

What motivates you?

 
 
 
 

What might tempt you to leave?

 
 
 
 

Please include any additional comments about your job or the company:

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

[i] https://www.shrm.org/resourcesandtools/hr-topics/employee-relations/pages/stay-interview-how-to-core-features-and-advantages.aspx

[ii] https://www.shrm.org/resourcesandtools/hr-topics/employee-relations/pages/stay-interview-how-to-core-features-and-advantages.aspx

[iii] https://www.shrm.org/resourcesandtools/hr-topics/employee-relations/pages/stay-interview-how-to-core-features-and-advantages.aspx

Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act (WARN) Federal vs. New York States “Mini-WARN” Act,  Severance Pay Considerations & Outplacement Service

Proposed: New York State Fair Warning Act

2023 NYS Highlighted WARN Notice Requirements

The WARN Act protects workers, families and communities if an organization has a foreseen or unforeseen plant closure or mass layoff.  The goal for all of our organizations is to never be in a position for mass layoffs however, understanding the difference in Federal vs. New York State specific laws is necessary, to ensure legal compliance.  New York State is one of the few states that has a “Mini-WARN” Act with stricter regulations than federal law.

Federal:
Requiring employers with 100 or more employees (generally not counting those who have worked less than six months in the last 12 months and those who work an average of less than 20 hours a week) to provide at least 60 calendar days advance written notice of a plant closing and mass layoff affecting 50 or more employees at a single site of employment. WARN makes certain exceptions to the requirements when layoffs occur due to unforeseeable business circumstances, faltering companies, and natural disasters. Advance notice gives workers and their families some transition time to adjust to the prospective loss of employment, to seek and obtain other jobs, and if necessary, to enter skill training or retraining that will allow these workers to compete successfully in the job market. Regular federal, state, local, and federally recognized Indian Tribal government entities that provide public services are not covered. (DOL)

State:
The WARN Act applies to private businesses with 50 or more full time workers in New York State. It covers:

  • Closings affecting 25 or more workers
  • Mass layoffs involving 25 or more full-time workers (if the 25 or more workers make up at least 33% of all the workers at the site)
  • Mass layoffs involving 250 or more full-time workers
  • Certain other relocations and covered reductions in work hours

This means that covered businesses must provide all employees with notice 90 days prior to a:

  • Plant closing
  • Mass layoff
  • Relocation
  • Other covered reduction in work hours

Businesses that do not provide notice may be required to:

  • Pay back wages and benefits to workers
  • Pay a civil penalty

Early warning gives the DOL and the LWIB the chance to work with the business early on and provide employees with information about:

  • Unemployment Insurance (UI)
  • Workforce Programs
  • Resources designed to get employees back to work quickly

Early warning also benefits the business. It can shorten the time that workers are on UI. It therefore may lower the UI charges associated with the layoff or closing. (NYS DOL)

As of late 2025/early 2026, the New York State (NYS) WARN Act mandates stricter compliance, requiring 90 days’ notice for layoffs/closures. Recent updates include incorporating remote workers into site counts, requiring disclosure of AI usage in selection decisions, and adding notifications to local officials, school districts, and emergency services. 


Key NYS WARN Act Changes & Requirements

  • AI/Algorithmic Disclosure (New): The DOL submission form now asks if AI or algorithmic tools were used to determine layoffs, requiring a yes/no answer and explanation.
  • Remote Worker Inclusion: Employees working remotely are now considered based at the site to which they report for calculating whether the threshold is met.
  • Expanded Notification Recipients: Notices must now be sent to the chief elected official of the local government, school districts, and local emergency service providers (police/fire), in addition to the DOL and union representatives.
  • Increased Notice Period: Employers must provide 90 days’ advance notice (compared to 60 days under federal law).
  • Thresholds: Applies to private employers with 50+ full-time employees in NY, covering closings affecting 25+ employees, or mass layoffs of 25+ (if 1/3 of staff) or 250+ employees.
  • Sale of Business: Updated rules now apply to notice requirements during a sale of a business. 

Federal additional Links & Information:

Federal WARN ACT Plant Closings and Layoffs

Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act Compliance Assistance Materials

WARN EMPLOYER GUIDE

State Additional Links & Information:

NYS DOL WARN Website

NYS Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act PDF

NYC Information

On June 21, 2023, the New York Department of Labor’s amendments to the NY WARN Act.

Employer Coverage
Under the amended regulations, the definition of a covered employer is expanded to count not just employees at a single site of employment in the state, but also employees who work remotely but are “based at the employment site.”

New Notice Content Requirements
On top of NY WARN’s already long list of notice content requirements, the amended regulations add that the notice to the New York Commissioner of Labor must include:

  1. business addresses and email addresses for the employer’s and employees’ agents;
  2. the personal telephone numbers, personal email addresses (if known), work locations, part-time/full-time status, method of payment (i.e., hourly, salary, or commission basis), and union affiliation for each affected employee;
  3. the total number of full-time employees in New York State and at each affected site, as well as the number of affected employees at each affected site; and
  4. the total number of part-time employees in New York State and at each affected site, as well as the number of affected employees at each affected site.

Notice to affected employees must now also include relevant information known at the time of the notice, such as information on severance packages or financial incentives if the employee remains and works until the effective date of the layoff, available dislocated worker assistance, and, if the planned action is expected to be temporary, the estimated duration.

Revisions to the Sale of Business Provision and NY WARN Exceptions
NY WARN’s sale of business provision was amended to clarify that sellers will not have an obligation to give WARN notice if the transfer of employees in the sale is a good-faith condition of the purchase agreement, and the purchasing employer does not uphold that condition. In that scenario, the purchasing employer would need to provide notice.

Additionally, NY WARN’s exceptions, which permit an employer in some cases to give less than the full 90-days’ notice to affected employees, remain in place with some tweaks:

  • The faltering company exception is now applicable only to plant closings (mirroring the federal WARN Act).
  • The unforeseeable business circumstances exception was amended to include public health emergencies, such as a pandemic, that result in a sudden and unexpected closure, and a terrorist attack directly affecting operations as new examples of circumstances that would qualify for this exception.

Older Workers Benefit Protection Act (OWBPA)

“An amendment to the Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA), the OWBPA is a federal law that requires employers to offer older workers (those who are at least 40 years old) benefits that are equal to or, in some cases, cost the employer as much as, the benefits it offers to younger workers. The OWBPA also sets minimum standards for an employee waiver of the right to sue for age discrimination, designed to ensure that the waiver is knowing and voluntary.” (Cornell Legal Information Institute)

The purposes of the Older Workers Benefit Protection Act (OWBPA) are to make it illegal for an employer to:

  • use an employee’s age as the basis for discrimination in benefits
  • target older workers for their staff-cutting programs, and
  • require older workers to waive their rights without observing certain safeguards.

Congressional Website
Additional Link

Additional State Mini-WARN Laws:

California’s WARN Act (Cal WARN) takes an approach to counting employees and layoffs that differs from the federal WARN Act, Hathaway noted. Cal WARN applies to “facilities” that have employed 75 or more people within the past 12 months. If 50 employees—employed for at least six months—are let go within a 30-day period, Cal WARN is triggered. Also, any closing of a covered facility triggers Cal WARN, even if fewer than 50 employees are let go, he explained.

The Iowa, New Hampshire, New York and Wisconsin WARN laws apply to layoffs involving as few as 25 employees, Hathaway said.

“New York requires 90 days’ notice, and New Jersey has a revision to its WARN law that has not yet gone into effect that also requires 90 days’ notice, plus separation pay equal to one week of pay per year of service,” he noted.

The mini-WARN Act in Illinois applies to employers with 75 or more full-time employees when: 1) 25 or more full-time employees are laid off if they constitute one-third or more of the full-time employees at the site or 2) 250 or more full-time employees are laid off, Hollis said.

Wisconsin’s mini-WARN Act applies to employers with at least 50 employees, he added.

“States continue to pass WARN-like requirements,” Hathaway said. “Be sure to know which states have done so.”

A city also can have a mini-WARN law. “As an example, Philadelphia has such a law, which can be surprising to employers.” (SHRM)

Key State-Specific WARN Act Provisions (as of 2026)

  • California (Cal-WARN): Covers employers with 75+ employees. Requires 60 days’ notice for layoffs, relocations, or terminations of 50+ employees within 30 days.
  • New York (NY-WARN): Covers employers with 50+ employees. Requires 90 days’ notice for plant closings, and lower thresholds for mass layoffs (33% of workforce or at least 25 employees).
  • New Jersey (NJ-WARN): Requires 90 days’ notice for employers with 100+ employees when laying off 50+ workers, and mandates severance pay for certain layoffs.
  • Illinois: Applies to employers with 75+ full-time employees, requiring 60 days’ notice for layoffs of 25+ employees (if they constitute 33% of the workforce) or 250+ employees.
  • Hawaii & Wisconsin: Both apply to employers with 50+ employees.
  • Other States: Additional states with specific mini-WARN laws include Delaware, Iowa, Maine, Maryland, New Hampshire, Ohio, Tennessee, and Vermont. 

Severance Legal Requirements

Federal Law Review and Revocation Periods

Under the federal Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA) and the Older Workers Benefit Protection Act (OWBPA), review periods depend on the employee’s age and the nature of the termination:

  • Individual Termination (Age 40+): Minimum 21 days to review the agreement.
  • Group Layoff / Reduction in Force (Age 40+): Minimum 45 days to review if two or more employees are laid off.
  • Federal Revocation Period: Mandatory 7 days to revoke the signature after signing an age discrimination waiver.

On March 4, 2025, the New York state Senate passed S.372, the “No Severance Ultimatums Act” a first of its kind legislation which, if enacted, will require New York employers to:

Provide a minimum 21 business days for employees to review severance agreements (which is waivable by the employee), and a nonwaivable seven-day revocation period after signing, and notify employees of their right to consult with an attorney before signing the agreement.

  • California: SB 331 (passed in 2022) requires employers to provide all employees at least five business days to review a severance agreement and notify employees of their right to consult with an attorney. California however does not require employers to require a revocation period after signing.
  • Minnesota: Under the Minnesota Human Rights Act (MHRA), prospective claims of the MHRA cannot be released in a severance agreement. Additionally, if a severance agreement includes a release of claims existing at the time of execution related to workplace discrimination, harassment or retaliation, employees have the right to rescind the release of MHRA claims within 15 days (written agreements) or 45 days (for electronic agreements) after signing.
  • New York: Existing New York law already requires a 21-day (waivable) review period and a mandatory seven-day revocation period for settlement agreements resolving discrimination, harassment or retaliation claims, when the employer includes a non-disclosure provision (at the employee’s choice) regarding the facts of the claim. Employers must provide this in a separate agreement for review and signature before signing the full settlement agreement.

No Severance Ultimatum Act- NYS

The Act adds a new Section 215-d to the New York Labor Law (“NYLL”) and prohibits so-called “coercive severance ultimatums.” Specifically, the Act requires that employers provide separating employees additional time and information before such employees release waivable claims. The Act would apply to all New York employees. Notably, the Act expressly includes governmental agencies in its definition of “employer.”

Under the Act, any employer offering a “severance agreement,” defined as an agreement offered upon separation of employment that requires the employee to release waivable claims against the employer, must notify the employee that:

  • The employee has a right to consult an attorney about the agreement;
  • The employee has at least twenty-one (21) calendar days to consider the agreement;
  • The employee may revoke the agreement within seven (7) calendar days of signing;
  • The agreement does not become effective and enforceable until after the revocation period expires; and
  • The employee may make a knowing and voluntary choice to sign the agreement prior to the end of the consideration period, provided such decision is not induced by the employer through fraud, misrepresentation, a threat to withdraw or alter the consideration period, or by providing different terms if the employee signs early.

Severance Pay Considerations

The firm’s 2014 Guide to Severance and Workforce Transition reflects the results of a survey of over 250 HR professionals across a wide range of company sizes and industries in the U.S. For those organizations not offering severance to all employees in cases of involuntary separation, the following positions were eligible for severance payments:

 Officers (C-suite)—76 percent of respondents.

 All senior executives—84 percent.

 Managers—84 percent.

 Professionals—73 percent.

 Administrative/clerical employees—56 percent.

 No policy—12 percent.

 Don’t know—5 percent.

“Because reductions in force or organizational restructuring events often affect many more employees below the professional level than above it, not offering severance may have an effect on how a large number of employees choose to respond with legal action or speak about or represent the company in the media, within their social networks, and in online reviews, where their opinions may create a ripple effect,” the report points out.

Calculating Severance

Of the 48 percent of organizations that offered severance for all eligible employees, the top three factors in calculating severance payouts were:

 Years of service.

 Job level or title.

 Base salary.

When asked for the average amount of equivalent salary offered to employees of those organizations, the top three responses were:

 3 months.

 2 months.

 1 month.

“Factors such as employee level or tenure have often factored into severance calculations in the past; however, as the business landscape changes and the conversation in human resources includes more perspectives on fairness in compensation and reward, it will be interesting to see if severance [trends toward] standard calculations” for all employees, the report states.

Continuing Benefits

Employers with 20 or more employees are usually required to offer departing employees COBRA health insurance coverage and to notify their employees of the availability of such coverage. Among surveyed companies, 70 percent have a standard policy for COBRA health plan continuation for all employees in the event of a reduction in force. These companies indicated that they:

 Provide COBRA benefits continuance as required—35 percent of respondents.

 Pay COBRA/insurance premium payments directly to an insurance company—29 percent.

 Give employees a lump sum to fully cover COBRA/insurance premiums—9 percent.

 Give employees a lump sum to partially cover COBRA/insurance premiums—6 percent.

 Partially reimburse employees’ COBRA/insurance premium payments—6 percent.

 Fully reimburse employees’ COBRA/insurance premium payments—4 percent.



When paying severance on an ad hoc basis, employers should be careful to clearly establish that they retain discretion over whether to grant severance pay and that it is not automatic or a vested job right. Some of the more common administrative issues that should be addressed include the following:

  • Will severance benefits cease if a former employee obtains alternative employment during the severance pay period?
  • How will any benefit payments be handled?
  • Will former employees continue to be considered “employees” of the organization during severance pay periods with all the same rights and privileges as active employees?
  • Will individuals still considered to be employees be eligible for routine salary increases or adjustment during the severance period?
  • What approval process will be required for authorizing severance payments?
  • Will there be an appeal process?
  • How will severance payments be calculated, and what will be the basis used for calculating benefits?
  • Will benefits be paid in the form of a lump sum payment, or over time?
  • Will changes in policy have any impact on past and current recipients of severance pay benefits?
  • What funding mechanisms are to be used to fund severance benefits?
  • Can severance benefits be transferred, assigned or pledged to a third party?
  • Will employees be required to sign a waiver or release of claims prior to receiving severance benefits?
  • What impact will the employee’s receipt of severance pay have on unemployment insurance benefits for the employee and on the future premiums of the employer? (SHRM)

What to include

Having a clearly written and communicated policy regarding termination and severance pay benefits is highly advisable. However, unless governed by a collective bargaining agreement or state law, what an employer chooses to include in a severance pay policy is at its discretion.
The amount and type of compensation in any given severance agreement varies according to specific circumstances, but the amount of severance pay is typically based on a number of factors, including:

  • Length of the employee’s tenure with the employer.
  • Circumstances under which the employment relationship ended (e.g., employer downsizing, employee conduct or layoff).
  • The employer’s financial solvency or particular circumstances (e.g., filing for bankruptcy, experiencing economic growth).

A well-structured policy should reflect the employer’s organizational culture and philosophy. In drafting the policy, employers should consider incorporating provisions that:

  • Cover a range of common situations, such as downsizing resulting from changes to internal organizational structures or business reorganizations.
  • Specify that severance pay benefits will be paid only to employees who are actually laid off as a result of transfers in business ownership due to a merger or acquisition.
  • Specify whether periodic severance payments cease when former employees obtain alternative employment.
  • Require employees to sign a waiver or release absolving the employer from employment-related liability prior to remittance of any severance pay.
  • Stipulate that any waiver or release should comply with the detailed requirements of the OWBPA, which applies when a discharged employee is age 40 or older and is waiving or releasing ADEA claims.
  • Clearly spell out the purpose of severance pay benefits. Generally, the purpose defines the group or groups of employees who are eligible under the plan as well as the benefits and constraints of the plan.
  • Specifically state that the organization reserves the right to alter or terminate the policy at its discretion. (SHRM)
https://www.shrm.org/topics-tools/tools/toolkits/designing-administering-severance-pay-plansDraft Policy (SHRM) Consider all local and state laws prior to implementation.

Severance Pay Policy
Purpose
The purpose of this policy is to outline the severance pay benefit of [Company Name].

Eligibility
This policy applies to all exempt and nonexempt, full-time and part-time employees. Part-time employees will receive severance pay on a pro-rated basis in accordance with their scheduled hours.

Triggering Events
In the event of an involuntary termination due to a reduction in force/downsizing, change in company direction, job elimination or termination for performance, [Company Name] provides a severance benefit for the affected employees. This does not apply to terminations for cause, refusal to be reassigned or refusal to be relocated.

Payment Amount
The rate of severance is based on length of service with [Company Name] (or as adjusted through acquisition).

Length of Service                  Number of Weeks
Less than one year                              2
One year – less than two                     3
Two years – less than three                 4
Three years – less than four                5
Four years – less than five                   6
Five years – less than six                     7
Six years or more                                8

The maximum allowed severance is eight weeks. Severance is calculated on base pay only. Employees may choose to receive severance pay as a salary continuation benefit (continue payments on scheduled paydays) or in a lump sum. Federal, state and local tax withholding will apply.

Vacation
Accrued but unused vacation will be paid out to the employee. Vacation will stop accruing as of the effective date of termination.

Commissions
Any commissions earned as of the date of the termination will be paid out.

Insurance Benefits
Health and dental insurance coverage, if applicable, end on the last day of the month in which the employee receives the severance benefit. Upon termination of coverage, COBRA notification will be forwarded.

Reduction in Force Policy – Selection and Severance Pay

A reduction in force (RIF) occurs when changing priorities, budgetary constraints or other business conditions require [Company Name] to eliminate positions.

Selection for RIF

A RIF decision requires an evaluation of the need for particular positions and the relative value of work performed by specific employees so that [Company Name] can continue to provide the highest level of service possible with a reduced work force. Determining the retention or separation of an employee includes an evaluation of the relative skills, knowledge and productivity of the employee in comparison to necessary services. Length of service and other factors are also considered but receive less weight in the determination. [Company Name] determines priority for RIF within the following guidelines:

  • Temporary employees performing the same work must be terminated before any regular employee, provided that a regular employee can perform the temporary employee’s tasks.
  • Reduction in force of regular employees is based on the following factors:
    • Which positions are most critical to the department in the delivery of goods or services.
    • Relative skills, knowledge and productivity of employees.
    • Length of service of employees.
    • Consideration of equal employment factors to avoid adverse impact on [Company Name]’s affirmative action goals.

Severance Pay
Severance pay is available for eligible employees in accordance with [Company Name]’s RIF determination process.

Severance pay calculation
The amount of an eligible employee’s severance payment is based on length of service and salary at separation. Payment is made in the same number of months as the number of months of pay. Payment is discontinued once re-employment is obtained.

Years of ServicePayment
Less than 1 year2 weeks’ base salary
1 but less than 5 years1 month base salary
5 but less than 10 years2 months’ base salary
10 but less than 20 years3 months’ base salary
20 or more years4 months’ base salary

[Optional section, where allowable under state law:]

Age Adjustment
An employee qualifies for an age adjustment factor at 40 years of age. To compute the amount of the adjustment, 2.5 percent of the annual base salary at separation is added for each full year of age over 39 years of age. The total age adjustment factor cannot exceed the total service payment.

Example: Age 47, salary – $48,000/year, 9 years’ service

FactorComputationAmount of Severance Pay
Service$4,000/month for 2 months$8,000
 
Age adjustment
$48,000 x .025 x (47-39) = $9,600
Age adjustment factor cannot exceed the service factor, so the age factor is limited to $8,000.
$8,000
 Total$16,000 distributed over 2 months

Deductions from severance pay
The following deductions must be withheld from severance payments.

DeductionAmount
Federal withholdingBased on an employee’s current withholding status on W-4
Garnishments, support orders, leviesAll based on directive provided
Negative leave balances, where allowableBased on leave balances

The following deductions will not be withheld from severance payments:

  • State income withholding tax (if permitted by the employee’s state).
  • Medical insurance, including health, dental and vision.
  • 401(k) and deferred compensation.
  • 401(k) loan payments.
  • Life insurance.

Direct deposit
Severance payments, as well as any leave payout due, will continue to be directly deposited into the bank account currently set up. To change to a different account, contact the payroll office.

Other RIF Benefits
Unemployment insurance
Employees separated due to RIF are eligible to collect unemployment insurance provided they otherwise meet the state eligibility requirements. Contact the local unemployment office to file a claim for unemployment compensation.

Vacation balance
Vacation leave is paid for a maximum of [insert amount] hours.
 
What is Outplacement Service?



Outplacement services offer a multitude of benefits for both the employee and the employer.

For the Employee:

  • Career Counseling and Guidance: Outplacement provides access to experienced career counselors who can help employees assess their skills, interests, and career goals. Counselors offer personalized guidance on career paths, job search strategies, and professional development.
  • Resume and Cover Letter Assistance: Crafting a compelling resume and cover letter is crucial for a successful job search. Outplacement services offer expert assistance in developing these documents, highlighting the employees’ strengths and accomplishments in a way that resonates with potential employers.
  • Interview Skills Training: Many people find interviewing stressful. Outplacement programs include interview skills training, equipping employees with the techniques and confidence to excel in job interviews. This may include mock interviews, feedback on communication style, and strategies for answering common interview questions.
  • Job Search Resources and Networking: Outplacement services provide access to a wealth of job search resources, including job boards, company directories, and networking opportunities. Counselors can help employees identify potential employers and connect with industry contacts.
  • Emotional Support: Losing a job can be emotionally challenging. Outplacement services offer emotional support and guidance to help employees cope with the stress and uncertainty of job loss. Counselors can provide a safe space to process emotions and develop coping strategies.
  • Negotiation Skills: Outplacement services can assist employees in negotiating salary and benefits with potential employers.

For the Employer:

  • Improved Employee Morale: Offering outplacement services demonstrates that the employer cares about the well-being of its employees, even after they leave the company. This can help maintain morale among remaining employees and reduce the risk of negative publicity.
  • Reduced Legal Risk: Providing outplacement services can help mitigate the risk of legal action from departing employees. By offering support and resources, employers can demonstrate that they are treating employees fairly and respectfully.
  • Enhanced Reputation: Companies that offer outplacement services are often viewed as more socially responsible and ethical. This can enhance the company’s reputation and attract top talent in the future.
  • Smoother Transition: Outplacement services can help ensure a smoother transition for both the departing employees and the remaining team. By providing support and resources, employers can minimize disruption and maintain productivity.
  • Positive Brand Image: Treating departing employees with respect and dignity can positively impact the company’s brand image. This can be particularly important in today’s social media-driven world, where negative experiences can quickly go viral.

Key Components of Outplacement Services
Outplacement services typically include a range of components designed to support the employee’s job search. These components may include:

  • Assessment: An initial assessment to identify the employee’s skills, interests, and career goals.
  • Career Counseling: One-on-one counseling sessions with an experienced career coach.
  • Resume and Cover Letter Development: Assistance in creating professional and effective resumes and cover letters.
  • Interview Skills Training: Workshops and practice sessions to improve interview performance.
  • Job Search Strategy Development: Guidance on developing a targeted job search strategy.
  • Networking Opportunities: Access to networking events and industry contacts.
  • Online Resources: Access to online job boards, company directories, and other resources.
  • Administrative Support: Assistance with administrative tasks such as scheduling interviews and preparing documents.
  • Negotiation Support: Assistance with negotiating salary and benefits.

Types of Outplacement Services
Outplacement services are not one-size-fits-all. They can be tailored to meet the specific needs of the employee and the employer. Common types of outplacement services include:

  • Individual Outplacement: This is the most common type of outplacement service, providing personalized support to individual employees.
  • Group Outplacement: This type of service is offered to groups of employees who are being laid off at the same time. It typically includes workshops and group counseling sessions.
  • Executive Outplacement: This type of service is designed for senior-level executives and typically includes more intensive coaching and support.
  • Virtual Outplacement: This type of service is delivered online, providing employees with access to resources and support from anywhere in the world.

Talentscape’s Outplacement Services
Talentscape’s outplacement services are designed to empower departing employees and equip them with the tools and support they need to successfully navigate their career transitions. Here’s how:

  • Personalized Career Coaching: Every individual’s situation is unique. Talentscape provides one-on-one coaching sessions with experienced career consultants who take the time to understand each participant’s skills, experience, goals, and challenges. This personalized approach ensures that the advice and guidance provided are relevant and effective. Coaches help participants identify their strengths, explore career options, and develop a tailored job search strategy.
  • Resume and Cover Letter Optimization: A strong resume and compelling cover letter are essential for making a positive first impression on potential employers. Talentscape’s experts work with participants to craft professional, ATS-friendly resumes and targeted cover letters that highlight their accomplishments and showcase their value.
  • Interview Skills Training: Mastering the art of interviewing is crucial for landing a job. Talentscape offers comprehensive interview skills training, including mock interviews, feedback on communication style, and guidance on how to answer common interview questions effectively. Participants learn how to confidently present themselves and articulate their qualifications.
  • Networking Opportunities: Networking is a powerful tool for job seekers. Talentscape helps participants expand their professional networks by providing access to industry contacts, alumni networks, and online communities. Coaches also provide guidance on how to effectively network and build relationships.
  • Job Search Resources and Technology: Talentscape provides access to a wealth of job search resources, including online job boards, company directories, and industry research tools. Participants also benefit from access to cutting-edge technology platforms that streamline the job search process and help them track their progress.
  • Emotional Support and Guidance: Job loss can be a stressful and emotional experience. Talentscape provides a supportive and understanding environment where participants can process their emotions, build their confidence, and stay motivated throughout their job search. Coaches offer encouragement, guidance, and practical advice to help participants overcome challenges and stay focused on their goals.

Benefits for Employers
Offering outplacement services is not just a compassionate gesture; it’s a strategic investment that can benefit employers in numerous ways:

  • Enhanced Employer Brand: Providing outplacement services demonstrates a commitment to employee well-being and reinforces a positive employer brand. This can improve employee morale, attract top talent, and enhance the company’s reputation in the marketplace.
  • Reduced Legal Risks: Outplacement services can help mitigate the risk of legal claims related to terminations. By providing departing employees with support and resources, companies can reduce the likelihood of wrongful termination lawsuits and other legal challenges.
  • Improved Employee Morale and Productivity: When employees see that their company cares about their future, even after they leave, it can boost morale and productivity among remaining employees. This can lead to a more engaged and motivated workforce.
  • Smoother Transitions: Outplacement services can help ensure a smoother transition for both departing employees and the company. By providing support and guidance, companies can minimize disruption and maintain productivity during periods of change.
  • Cost Savings: While outplacement services involve an initial investment, they can ultimately lead to cost savings by reducing legal risks, improving employee morale, and minimizing disruption.
  • Positive Public Relations: Offering outplacement services can generate positive public relations and enhance the company’s image as a responsible and caring employer.

Why Talentscape Stands Out
Talentscape distinguishes itself from other outplacement providers through its:

  • Customized Approach: We understand that every organization and every employee has unique needs. Our programs are tailored to meet those specific requirements.
  • Experienced and Dedicated Coaches: Our team of career coaches comprises seasoned professionals with extensive experience in various industries. They are passionate about helping individuals achieve their career goals.
  • Cutting-Edge Technology: We leverage the latest technology to provide participants with access to a comprehensive suite of job search tools and resources.
  • Proven Track Record: We have a proven track record of helping individuals successfully transition to new roles.
  • Commitment to Client Satisfaction: We are committed to providing exceptional service and exceeding our clients’ expectations.

New York City’s Predictable-Scheduling Law

On February 18, 2020, “State Trial Judge Arthur Engoron dismissed a lawsuit, finding that the city’s scheduling regulation isn’t pre-empted by state law. Covered employers in the Big Apple, therefore, must continue to ensure that their policies and practices align with employee-scheduling rules outlined in the 2017 Fair Workweek Law.” (SHRM)  What this means in NYC?  Fast-Food and retail employers throughout New York City must comply with both the city’s predictable-scheduling law and New York State’s wage and hour laws.  Don’t forget the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) at the federal level.  The original NYC laws were passed in late 2017.



New York City’s Fair Workweek Laws Fast-Food Employees:

“Under the Fair Workweek Law, fast food employees have the right to:

  1. Good Faith Estimate of Schedule:
    On or before workers’ first day of work, employers must provide written schedules for the first two weeks of work with hours, dates, start and end times of shifts and written “Good Faith Estimates” (days, times, hours, locations you can expect to work during your employment). Employers must provide an updated estimate if the estimate changes.
  2. Advanced Notice of Work Schedules:
    Employers must give workers their written work schedule at least 14 days before their first shift in the schedule. Schedules must include at least seven calendar days with dates, shift start and end times, and location(s) of all shifts. If the schedule changes, employers must contact all affected workers within 24 hours, or as soon as possible.
  3. Priority to Work Newly Available Shifts:
    Before hiring a new employee when new shifts become available, employers must advertise shifts to existing workers in NYC first by: 1) posting information at the worksite where the shifts have become available and by directly providing the information to workers electronically, which may include via text or email; 2) giving priority to work open shifts to workers at the worksite where shifts are available; 3) giving shifts to interested workers from other worksites only when no or not enough workers from the worksite accept. Employers can only hire new workers if no current NYC workers accept the shifts by the posted deadline.
  4. Consent Plus $100 for “Clopening” Shifts:
    Employers cannot schedule workers to work two shifts over two days when the first shift ends a day and when there are less than 11 hours between shifts (a “clopening”) UNLESS workers consent in writing AND are paid a $100 premium to work the shift.” (NYC.gov)

New York City’s Fair Workweek Laws Fast-Food Employees:

“Under the Fair Workweek Law, retail employees have the right to:

  1. 72 Hours’ Advance Notice of Work Schedule:
    Employers must give workers their written work schedule at least 72 hours before the start of the schedule in the way the employer usually contacts workers, which may include via text and email. They must post the schedule at the workplace where all workers can see it. This schedule must include dates, shift start and end times, and location(s) of all shifts in the work schedule. If the schedule is changed, employers must update and repost the schedule and contact all affected workers.
  2. No On-call Shifts:
    Employers cannot require workers to be ready and available to work at any time the employer demands, regardless of whether workers actually work or report to work; or to “check in” within 72 hours of a scheduled shift to find out if they should report for the shift.
  3. No Shift Additions with Less than 72 Hours’ Notice:
    If employers want to add time or shifts to your schedule less than 72 hours before the change, workers have the right to accept or decline the change. If workers accept an additional shift, they must do so in writing.
  4. No Shift Cancellations with Less than 72 Hours’ Notice:
    Employers cannot cancel a shift less than 72 hours before the start of the shift except under the following circumstances: threats to worker safety or employer property, public utility failure, shutdown of public transportation, fire, flood, or other natural disaster, or a government-declared state of emergency. However, workers may trade shifts voluntarily.” (NYC.gov)

The legislation also contains fast-food employee’s right to voluntary deductions and contributions to a nonprofit, revoking authorization and receiving information about the nonprofit. 

Predictable Scheduling Fast-Food Posting

Predictable Scheduling Retail Posting

Fast Food Deductions

Fair Workweek: Fast Food

Fair Workweek: RetailDeductions
FAQs

Employee Complaint Forms: Fair Workweek: Fast FoodFair Workweek: RetailDeductions

New York State Definitions for Fast-Food & Retail Establishments:

WHAT IS A FAST FOOD ESTABLISHMENT?
A fast food establishment is any business that meets the following criteria:

  • Primarily serves food or drinks, including coffee shops, juice bars, donut shops, and ice cream parlors
  • Offers limited service, where customers order and pay before eating, including restaurants with tables but without full table service, and places that only provide take-out service
  • Is part of a chain of 30 or more locations, including individually owned establishments associated with a brand that has 30 or more locations nationally

Examples of fast food establishments include Ben & Jerry’s, Chipotle, Dunkin Donuts, Golden Krust Caribbean Bakery and Grill, Jamba Juice, KFC, McDonald’s, Nathan’s Famous, Pizza Hut, Quiznos, Shake Shack, Starbucks, Subway, Taco Bell, Tim Hortons, Uno Pizzeria & Grill, Wendy’s, and White Castle.” (NY DOL Website)

RETAIL DEFINITION:
“”Retail store” shall mean a store that sells stock-keeping units directly to consumers and charges or is liable for the collection of sales taxes. For the purposes of this section the term “retail store” shall include those stores that use Universal Product Code (UPC) scanners or price-look-up (PLU) codes in checkout systems or use manual pricing of items.” (NYS Senate Website)

What impact does this have on the “Remainder of New York State,” as defined by Albany?  There are no current impacts on retail or fast-food establishments throughout the remainder of the state.  However, I say “current impacts.”  As California and New York City pass laws, there is at times a domino impact throughout the remainder of the state. 

Continue to watch for any changes in NYC and/or California related to these laws and any other labor and employment laws.  If you have locations in NYC, I am happy to answer any questions on these laws.

States with Statewide Laws

  • Oregon: Only state with a broad law for large retail/hospitality/food service (500+ employees), requiring 7 days’ notice and predictability pay. 

Key Cities with Local Laws (Examples)

  • New York City: Retail/Fast Food: 14-day notice, predictability pay for changes, right to decline shifts.
  • Chicago: Retail/Food Service/Hotels/Manufacturing/Warehouse: 14-day notice, predictability pay.
  • Seattle: Retail/Food Service: 14-day notice, predictability pay.
  • Los Angeles: Some sectors: Notice, predictability pay.
  • San Francisco: Advance notice (2 weeks), predictability pay. 

https://www.paycom.com/resources/blog/predictive-scheduling-laws/
https://www.hrdive.com/news/a-running-list-of-states-and-localities-with-predictive-scheduling-mandates/540835/

Additional State and Local Information on Predictive Scheduling (HR Dive)

ARKANSAS
State-wide

Effective Date: March 24, 2017
Employers Affected: None
Local governments may not create or adopt employer requirements outside state or federal requirements.
View the law

CALIFORNIA
San Francisco

Effective Date: July 3, 2015
Employers Affected: “Formula Retail Use” employers in San Francisco with at least 40 retail sales establishments worldwide. Includes bars, restaurants, liquor stores, sales and service providers (including banks and other financial institutions) and take-out food shops. More information on a Formula Retail Use employer can be found here.
The Formula Retail Employee Rights Ordinances (FRERO) regulate hours, notice of work schedules and predictability pay for schedule changes and on-call shifts. Employers must provide schedules two weeks in advance and provide a “good faith written estimate” of the expected number of scheduled shifts per month and the days and hours of those shifts when an employee starts working.
View the law

Emeryville

Effective Date: Jan. 1, 2018
Employers Affected: Retail employers with 56 or more employees globally or fast food companies with 56 or more employees globally and 20 or more employees in Emeryville.
Affected employers in Emeryville must give a “good faith estimate” of an employee’s work schedule. Schedules should be given at least 14 days in advance or an employer must pay Predictability Pay in a calculation which can be seen in the final regulations linked below. Employees also get paid time-and-a-half if scheduled with two shifts within 11 hours of each other for every hour within that 11-hour window.
View the law

GEORGIA
State-wide
Effective Date: July 1, 2017
Employers Affected: None
Local governments may not create or adopt minimum wage laws or laws that require “additional pay to employees based on schedule changes.”
View the law


ILLINOIS
Chicago

Effective Date: July 1, 2020
Employers Affected: Businesses with 100 or more employees, nonprofits with more than 250 employees, restaurants with at least 30 locations and 250 employees globally. To be eligible, employees must earn less than or equal to $26.00 per hour or earn less than or equal to $50,000 per year as a salaried employee.

The Chicago Fair Workweek Ordinance includes building services, healthcare providers, hotels and manufacturers, as well as the standard retail and food service occupations. Employers must give 10 days’ notice of workers’ schedules; that window will rise to 14 days on July 1, 2022. Employers that make alterations to schedules after that 10-day deadline without mutual agreement to the change must pay one hour of Predictability Pay (one hour of the employee’s regular rate) for each adjusted shift. Employees have the right to decline shifts that start less than 10 hours after the end of the previous shift. Employees that do work shifts that begin less than 10 hours after the end of the previous shift must be paid at a rate of 1.25 times their regular rate of pay. This ordinance, due to its scope, also has a number of exceptions, which can be viewed in the law linked below.
View the law


IOWA
State-wide

Effective Date: March 30, 2017
Employers Affected: None
Local governments may not create or adopt regulations “relating to employment matters.”
View the law

OREGON
State-wide

Effective Date: Aug. 8, 2017
Employers Affected: Employers in the retail, hospitality and food service industries that have at least 500 employees.

Currently, employers must provide written work schedules at least seven days in advance, provide a good faith estimate of hours upon hiring and give workers a rest period of at least 10 hours between two shifts or else pay a time-and-a-half rate if the employee opts to work that shift. By July 2020, employers must provide work schedules 14 days in advance.
View the law

Related Stories

Oregon becomes first state to require predictive scheduling

PENNSYLVANIA
Philadelphia

Effective Date: April 1, 2020
Employers Affected: Employers in the retail, hospitality and food service industries that have at least 250 employees and 30 locations worldwide.
Employers must provide a good faith estimate of a new employee’s work schedule, though this requirement will not be in effect until July 1, 2020. Notice of schedules must be given 10 days in advance in 2020, and then 14 days in advance starting Jan. 1, 2021. Employers that change the schedule after the advance notice period must pay the affected employees one hour of predictability pay. Employees are also entitled to a rest period of at least 9 hours between two shifts or pay $40 to the worker for each shift worked within such a period.
View the law

TENNESSEE
State-wide

Effective Date: April 19, 2017
Employers Affected: None
Local governments are not allowed to adopt or enforce any regulations that impose “a requirement upon an employer pertaining to employee scheduling.”
View the law


WASHINGTON
Seattle

Effective Date: July 1, 2017
Employers Affected: Retail and food service establishments with 500 or more employees worldwide and restaurants with 500 or more employees and 40 or more locations worldwide.
Employers must provide a good faith estimate of hours an employee can expect upon hire, cannot schedule shifts separated by less than 10 hours unless an employee consents to work such hours at a time-and-a-half rate, and must provide work schedules 14 days in advance or pay workers at least an extra hour at the standard rate.
View the ordinance

What is No-Fault Attendance Laws and Regulations & 8 Thoughts on Chronic Absenteeism

New York has the most restrictive law, prohibiting discipline for legally protected absences (like FMLA, disability, religious needs) under “no-fault” policies, making it the closest to having a “no-fault ban” for those crucial leaves. Other states, like California, also have strong laws (CFRA, PDL) protecting specific leaves, meaning employers must always account for these protected reasons, even in general point systems. 

Key State Examples

  • New York (NY): Since February 2023, NY Labor Law § 215 prohibits employers from disciplining or retaliating against employees for lawful absences protected by federal, state, or local law, effectively restricting traditional no-fault systems for such leaves.
  • California (CA): State laws like the California Family Rights Act (CFRA) and Pregnancy Disability Leave (PDL) require employers to allow protected leave, meaning any attendance policy must exclude these absences from points or penalties. 

What These Policies Mean

  • No-Fault Policies: These systems track absences (tardies, no-shows) and assign points regardless of the reason, leading to discipline if a threshold is met.
  • Legally Protected Absences: Even in states without explicit bans, federal and state laws (like FMLA, ADA, state sick leave laws) mandate certain leaves (e.g., serious health conditions, disability accommodations, family needs) that cannot be penalized under a standard no-fault system. 

What are No-Fault Attendance Policies?

No-fault attendance policies, also known as point-based or occurrence-based attendance policies, are disciplinary systems that address employee absenteeism and tardiness regardless of the reason for the absence. Unlike traditional attendance policies that distinguish between excused and unexcused absences, no-fault policies treat all absences the same, with certain exceptions.

The core principle is that consistent attendance is essential for business operations, and excessive absenteeism, regardless of the cause, disrupts productivity and imposes costs on the employer. These policies aim to create a clear, objective, and consistently applied system for managing attendance.

Key Features of No-Fault Attendance Policies

Several key features characterize no-fault attendance policies:

  • Point System: Employees accrue points for each absence or instance of tardiness. The number of points assigned may vary depending on the duration of the absence or the lateness.
  • Progressive Discipline: As an employee accumulates points, they progress through a series of disciplinary actions, such as verbal warnings, written warnings, suspensions, and ultimately, termination.
  • Point Decay or Restoration: Some policies include a mechanism for points to decay or be restored over time if the employee maintains good attendance. This incentivizes improved attendance behavior.
  • Specific Point Thresholds: The policy clearly defines the point thresholds for each disciplinary action, ensuring transparency and consistency.
  • Limited Exceptions: While the policy is generally “no-fault,” most policies include exceptions for absences protected by law, such as those covered by the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), or workers’ compensation laws.
  • Clear Communication: The policy is clearly communicated to all employees, outlining the rules, point system, disciplinary actions, and exceptions.

Legal Considerations

While no-fault attendance policies offer administrative simplicity, employers must be mindful of several legal considerations:

  • FMLA: The Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) provides eligible employees with up to 12 weeks of unpaid, job-protected leave for specified family and medical reasons. Employers cannot penalize employees for taking FMLA-protected leave under a no-fault attendance policy.
  • ADA: The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) requires employers to provide reasonable accommodations to qualified individuals with disabilities. This may include modifying attendance policies to accommodate disability-related absences. Employers must engage in an interactive process with employees to determine if a reasonable accommodation is possible.
  • Workers’ Compensation: Employees who are absent due to work-related injuries or illnesses are typically protected under workers’ compensation laws. Employers cannot penalize employees for absences related to compensable injuries or illnesses.
  • Discrimination: Employers must ensure that no-fault attendance policies are applied consistently and do not disproportionately impact protected groups, such as employees based on race, gender, religion, or age.
  • State and Local Laws: Some states and localities have laws that provide additional protections for employees regarding sick leave or other types of leave. Employers must comply with these laws when implementing and administering no-fault attendance policies.
  • Contractual Obligations: Collective bargaining agreements or employment contracts may contain provisions related to attendance policies. Employers must adhere to these contractual obligations.

Advantages of No-Fault Attendance Policies

  • Simplicity and Objectivity: No-fault policies are relatively simple to administer and provide a clear, objective standard for evaluating attendance.
  • Consistency: The consistent application of the policy can reduce claims of favoritism or discrimination.
  • Reduced Administrative Burden: Eliminating the need to evaluate the reasons for absences can save time and resources for HR and management.
  • Improved Attendance: The policy can incentivize employees to improve their attendance by creating a clear consequence for absences.
  • Focus on Performance: By addressing absenteeism, the policy can help improve overall employee performance and productivity.

Disadvantages of No-Fault Attendance Policies

  • Potential for Inequity: The policy may penalize employees for legitimate absences, such as those due to illness or family emergencies, which can lead to resentment and morale issues.
  • Risk of Legal Challenges: Failure to properly account for legally protected absences can result in legal challenges under the FMLA, ADA, or other laws.
  • Negative Impact on Employee Morale: Employees may feel that the policy is unfair or insensitive to their personal circumstances, which can negatively impact morale and engagement.
  • Presenteeism: Employees may come to work sick to avoid accruing points, which can spread illness and reduce productivity.
  • Difficulty in Addressing Underlying Issues: The policy may not address the underlying reasons for absenteeism, such as job dissatisfaction, stress, or health problems.
  • Potential for Abuse: Employees may strategically use their allowed absences, leading to predictable disruptions in workflow.

Best Practices for Implementing No-Fault Attendance Policies
To mitigate the potential disadvantages and ensure legal compliance, employers should consider the following best practices:

  • Clearly Define the Policy: The policy should be written in clear, concise language and easily accessible to all employees.
  • Provide Adequate Training: Managers and supervisors should be trained on how to administer the policy consistently and fairly.
  • Make Exceptions for Legally Protected Absences: The policy should clearly state that absences covered by the FMLA, ADA, workers’ compensation, and other applicable laws will not be counted against employees.
  • Consider a “Good Faith” Exception: Include a provision that allows for exceptions in extraordinary circumstances, such as natural disasters or family emergencies.
  • Offer Employee Assistance Programs (EAPs): Provide resources to help employees address underlying issues that may be contributing to absenteeism, such as stress, mental health problems, or substance abuse.
  • Regularly Review and Update the Policy: The policy should be reviewed and updated periodically to ensure compliance with changing laws and regulations and to address any unintended consequences.
  • Communicate Openly with Employees: Be transparent about the purpose of the policy and address any concerns or questions that employees may have.
  • Track Attendance Data: Monitor attendance data to identify trends and patterns and to evaluate the effectiveness of the policy.
  • Focus on Employee Well-being: Promote a culture of employee well-being and provide resources to help employees stay healthy and productive.

Many of our organizations have dealt with absenteeism, both chronic and occasional.  These absences do have an impact on all of our organizations from productivity to organizational culture and employee conflict/retaliation, turnover, etc.  “Each year, “US workers are absent from work for more than ½ billion work days…according to a 2016 report published by the CDC, productivity losses from missed work cost employers $225.8 billion, or $1,685 per employee, each year…absenteeism causes financial issues, loss of productivity and a decrease in workplace morale.”[i]

The yearly cost of employee absenteeism is 225.8 billion dollars.

There’s no doubt about it: $225.8 billion is a lot of money…that comes out to $1,685 per employee, per year. Why is absenteeism so costly? Absenteeism not only reduces productivity, but can also lead to increased spending on hiring and onboarding new employees, paying overtime for employees covering open shifts, and unplanned downtime.
https://www.teamsense.com/blog/absenteeism-workplace-statistics

Chronic Absenteeism Definitions to Remember:

Employee absences fall within two broad categories:

  1. “Innocent”: Absences related to legitimate medical and/or personal issues and are out of the employee’s control
  2. “Culpable”: Absences that occur without genuine cause and are within the employee’s control

What about Statutory Interplay (laws and regulations that impact absenteeism)?

*These regulations and statutory interplay are specific to New York State, review your local and state laws and regulations, to ensure compliance, while ensuring a thorough understanding of the regulations prior to writing and enforcing attendance policies.

Thoughts on Chronic Absenteeism:

  1. Design, implement and communicate a legally compliant and effective attendance policy.
  2. Ensure your managers, supervisors and the rest of the organization is consistently enforcing the attendance policy.  Questions to consider:
    1. Are call-in procedures being followed?  Are we allowing text messages, Facebook messages, emails, etc.?
    2. Are we tracking call-ins?
    3. Are documentation procedures being followed?
    4. What about the aforementioned protected leave interplay?  Have we checked on this?
  3. Track attendance and review metrics on a regular basis.  We reviewed attendance metrics monthly as part of the Key Performance Indicators (KPI’s) at past organizations, during monthly operation review meetings.
  4. Conduct necessary follow-up when vague absence explanations that are being offered.  Ask for new FMLA paperwork or ADA paperwork.  Follow-up, but follow-up consistently.  Accountability from the organization and employees is necessary.
  5. Recognize and reward for good attendance records.  Ensure this is spelled out in the policy and implemented consistently throughout the organization.
  6. What about pattern absenteeism?
  7. Training and communication on the policy and handbook language?
  8. Rolling 12-month calendar?

These are just a few thoughts, definitions and recommendations on chronic absenteeism and attendance policies for all organizations.  I have written many of these policies for organizations and implemented attendance tracking metrics.  I’m happy to work with any organization in reviewing, revising, drafting, implementing and communicating attendance policies.  Consistency is the key to a successful attendance policy.  Ensure you review laws and regulations at the local, state and federal level prior to finalizing the attendance policy.

Example Attendance Policy (Review Local & State Considerations)

Objective
The purpose of this policy is to set forth for the Organization policy and procedures for handling employee absences and tardiness to promote the efficient operation of the company and minimize unscheduled absences. 

Policy
Punctual and regular attendance is an essential responsibility of each employee at the Organization.  Employees are expected to report to work as scheduled, on time and prepared to start working. Employees are also expected to remain at work for their entire work schedule. Late arrival, early departure or other absences from scheduled hours are disruptive and must be avoided.

This policy does not apply to absences covered by the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) or leave provided as a reasonable accommodation under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), New York State Paid Family Leave (PFL), New York State Paid Sick Leave (PSL), Workers Compensation, Paid COVID-19 Sick Leave (as applicable), Pregnancy Leave (PDA & PWFA), Religious Holidays, Jury Duty, Time Off to Vote, Bereavement Leave and any other protected leave as defined at the local, state, and federal level. These exceptions are described in separate policies.

Absence
“Absence” is defined as the failure of an employee to report for work when he or she is scheduled to work. The two types of absences are defined below:

Excused absence occurs when all the following conditions are met:

  • The employee provides to his or her supervisor sufficient notice advance of the absence.
  • The absence request is approved by the Human Resources Department or Supervisor.
  • Unexcused absence occurs when any of the above conditions are not met. If it is necessary for an employee to be absent or late for work because of an illness or an emergency, the employee must notify his or her supervisor no later than the employee’s scheduled starting time on that same day. If the employee is unable to call, he or she must have someone make the call.
    An unexcused absence counts as one occurrence for the purposes of discipline under this policy.

Employees with three or more consecutive days of excused absences because of illness or injury must give the Organization proof of physician’s care and a fitness for duty release prior to returning to work.

Employees must take earned PTO and/or PSL for every absence unless otherwise allowed by company policy (e.g., leave of absence, FMLA, bereavement, jury duty) if paid leave is available.

Call-In Procedure: Employees are expected to call in, text or email prior to any scheduled shift as soon as possible. Sick, Personal, Leave, PTO, etc. must be approved prior to using any leave. Approval must be submitted to the President. If you plan to take vacation time 5-10 days, please schedule 2-weeks in advance. Call-in includes intermittent FMLA, PFL leave, sick leave, etc. reserves the right to deny any leave if standards are not followed, employees not following procedures will be disciplined up to and including dismissal.

Tardiness and Early Departures
Employees are expected to report to work and return from scheduled breaks on time. If employees cannot report to work as scheduled, they must notify their supervisor no later than their regular starting time. This notification does not excuse the tardiness but simply notifies the supervisor that a schedule change may be necessary.
Employees who must leave work before the end of their scheduled shift must notify a supervisor immediately.
Tardiness and early departures are each one-half an occurrence for the purpose of discipline under this policy.

Chronic Absence or Tardiness
Employees receiving corrective action under this policy are expected to improve their attendance and punctuality. Failure to improve and sustain improvement may result in the employee’s receiving additional correction, up to and including termination.

Pattern Absenteeism
Is defined as late arrivals or missing scheduled days during a workweek, (showing up late on Monday morning or calling in sick on Monday). 

Disciplinary Action
Excessive absenteeism is defined as two or more occurrences of unexcused absence in a 30-day period and will result in disciplinary action. Eight occurrences of unexcused absence in a 12-month period are considered grounds for dismissal.

Job Abandonment
Any employee who fails to report to work for a period of three days or more without notifying his or her supervisor will be considered to have (AWOL) abandoned the job and voluntarily resigned from the employment relationship. 

Attendance Point System for Nonexempt Employees

Attendance and Punctuality
An unauthorized absence occurs when the employee’s supervisor/department has not been properly notified that an employee will be late or absent. Points will be assessed for unauthorized absences, tardiness or late arrivals as described below.
Absent – missing one or more consecutive scheduled workdays for a single reason or
                  arriving more than two hours after the scheduled starting time.
Tardy – arriving up to 15 minutes after the scheduled starting time.
Late – arriving between 15 minutes and two hours after the scheduled starting time.

AbsencePointsExplanation
1-14 minutes1Tardy
15 minutes-2 hours3Late
More than 2 hours5Unauthorized absence

Disciplinary Action
Employees will be subject to disciplinary action when the total points accumulated from unauthorized absences and tardiness reach the following levels during any rolling 12-month period.

PointsCorrective Action
10Verbal warning
15Written warning
20Termination

Perfect Attendance Objective
The Organization values employees with perfect attendance and recognizes nonexempt employees semiannually for perfect attendance on January 1 and July 1.

Eligibility
To receive an attendance award, the employee must have been a full-time employee during the previous six-month period and have used no sick leave, taken no time off without pay, had no unscheduled late arrivals or early departures that were not made up within the same workweek, and had no unscheduled PTO (without advanced notice). Absences covered by the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) or leave provided as a reasonable accommodation under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), New York State Paid Family Leave (PFL), New York State Paid Sick Leave (PSL), Workers Compensation, Paid COVID-19 Sick Leave (as applicable), Pregnancy Leave (PDA & PWFA) are not counted.

Perfect Attendance Award
The perfect-attendance award is $100 cash. This cash award is considered taxable income to the employee but will be “grossed up” to cover taxes so that the actual amount the employee realizes is $100. It will be included in the employee’s paycheck the first regularly scheduled payday following January 1 and July 1.


[i] Bond Slides

The Benefits of Using HR Metrics

Like most professional fields, Human Resources continues to undergo an evolution.  Once seen as an administrative function; payroll, policies, benefits, hiring, etc.  We continue to align the function with strategic goals and objectives or our respected organizations.  But what does that mean?  How are we aligning ourselves with these goals and objectives, without being seen as just a “cost center” and ensuring we have a “seat at the table?”

HR Metrics that align with the organization’s goals and objectives, while providing valuable insight to the decision-making processes.  As part of a strategic planning session, ask organizational leadership the following questions to gain a better insight into what is important to the organization in regard to HR Metrics:

  1. What HR metrics are important to the organization?
  2. What data do we need to gather and/or track to calculate these metrics?
  3. How will we analyze the data and what benchmarks will we use?
  4. Once we have the data what plan of action will be used, how will we develop and measure improvement?

Take it one step farther in the meeting and provide the team with commonly used examples, definitions and calculations to ensure accuracy and buy in.  Below is a list of commonly used HR Metrics, some will work for your organization, others will not and other’s will be need to be modified or tweaked to ensure the organization is measuring what it values:

Absence Rate:
Number days absent in month ÷ (average number of employees during a month x number of workdays)

Benefit Costs Per Employee:
            Total cost of employee benefits program/total number of employees

Benefits as a Percent of Salary:
            Annual benefits cost/annual salary

Cost Per Hire:
            Recruitment costs/ (compensation cost + benefits cost)

Engagement Rating:
            Percentage of employees engaged with a given aspect of the workplace

Percent of Performance Goals Met or Exceeded:
            Number of performance goals met or exceeded/ total number of performance goals

Time to Fill:
            Total days taken to fill a job/ number hired

Training and Development Hours:
            Sum of total training hours/ total number of employees

Tenure:
            Average number of years of service at the organization across all employees

Turnover (annual):
  Number of employees exiting the job during 12-month period/ average number of employees
(Turnover can be broken down into semiannual, monthly, etc.)

Turnover Costs:
            Total cost of separation + vacancy + replacement + training
(This number will vary depending on position, generally it is 6 to 12 months of salary)

Utilization Percent:
   Total number of employees utilizing a program, benefit or service/ total number of employee’s eligible

Workers Compensation Cost Per Employee:
            Total worker’s compensation costs per year/ average number of employees

Yield Ratio:
            Percentage of applicants from a recruitment source (indeed, monster, CareerBuilder, Craigslist) that make it to the next state in the selection process

These just a few examples of the many HR Metrics that can be implemented into any organization, without the buy in and agreement on which metrics to implement, the value significantly decreases.  Organizations I have worked for in the past have developed an “HR Dashboard,” to track key metrics that are important to the respected organization. 

Below is a link to examples of HR Dashboards:

https://www.template.net/business/hr-templates/hr-dashboard-template/

Knowing what is important to the organization will help to ensure a successful implementation of key HR Metrics.  

1. Improved Decision-Making
HR metrics provide a factual basis for decision-making. Instead of relying on intuition or anecdotal evidence, organizations can use data to understand workforce dynamics. For example, metrics such as turnover rates and employee satisfaction scores can help HR leaders identify issues before they escalate, allowing for timely interventions.

2. Enhanced Recruitment Processes
By analyzing recruitment metrics, organizations can refine their hiring processes. Metrics such as time-to-fill, cost-per-hire, and source of hire can reveal which recruitment channels are most effective. This data enables HR teams to allocate resources more efficiently and attract the right talent.

3. Increased Employee Engagement
Employee engagement metrics, such as participation in surveys and feedback mechanisms, provide insights into how employees feel about their work environment. By regularly measuring engagement levels, organizations can implement strategies to boost morale, leading to higher productivity and lower turnover rates.

4. Better Talent Management
HR metrics can help organizations identify high performers and those who may need additional support. By tracking performance metrics, organizations can tailor development programs to meet individual needs, fostering a culture of continuous improvement and professional growth.

5. Cost Efficiency
Understanding HR metrics can lead to significant cost savings. For instance, analyzing turnover rates can help organizations identify the root causes of employee departures. By addressing these issues, organizations can reduce recruitment and training costs associated with high turnover.

6. Compliance and Risk Management
HR metrics can also play a crucial role in ensuring compliance with labor laws and regulations. By tracking metrics related to diversity, equity, and inclusion, organizations can identify potential compliance issues and take proactive measures to mitigate risks.

7. Strategic Workforce Planning
HR metrics enable organizations to forecast future workforce needs based on current trends. By analyzing data related to employee demographics, skills, and performance, organizations can develop strategic plans for hiring, training, and succession planning.

8. Benchmarking Against Industry Standards
Organizations can use HR metrics to benchmark their performance against industry standards. This comparison can highlight areas where an organization excels or falls short, providing valuable insights for strategic planning and improvement.

Implementing HR Metrics
To effectively implement HR metrics, organizations should follow these steps:

1. Define Objectives
Clearly outline the objectives of using HR metrics. Whether it’s improving employee retention, enhancing recruitment processes, or increasing engagement, having specific goals will guide the selection of relevant metrics.

2. Select Relevant Metrics
Choose metrics that align with organizational goals. Common HR metrics include:

  • Turnover Rate: Measures the percentage of employees who leave the organization over a specific period.
  • Employee Satisfaction Index: Gauges employee happiness and engagement levels.
  • Training ROI: Assesses the return on investment for training programs.

3. Collect Data
Implement systems for collecting and analyzing data. This may involve using HR software, conducting surveys, or leveraging existing data sources.

4. Analyze and Interpret Data
Regularly analyze the collected data to identify trends and insights. Use visualization tools to present data in an easily digestible format for stakeholders.

5. Take Action
Based on the insights gained from HR metrics, implement strategies to address identified issues. Monitor the impact of these changes and adjust as necessary.

6. Review and Refine
Continuously review the effectiveness of HR metrics and refine them as needed. As organizational goals evolve, so too should the metrics used to measure success.

10 Common HR Metrics

  1. Employee Turnover Rate
  2. Definition:The employee turnover rate measures the percentage of employees who leave an organization over a specific period.
  3. Importance: High turnover can indicate issues within the workplace, such as poor management or lack of career advancement opportunities. Monitoring this metric helps HR identify trends and implement retention strategies.
  1. Time to Fill
  2. Definition: Time to fill measures the number of days it takes to fill a vacant position from the moment it is posted until an offer is accepted.
  3. Importance: This metric helps HR evaluate the efficiency of the recruitment process. A longer time to fill may indicate challenges in attracting suitable candidates or inefficiencies in the hiring process.
  1. Cost per Hire
  2. Definition: Cost per hire quantifies the total cost involved in hiring a new employee, including advertising, recruitment agency fees, and onboarding expenses.
  3. Importance: Understanding the cost per hire allows HR to budget effectively and assess the return on investment (ROI) of recruitment strategies.
  1. Employee Engagement Score
  2. Definition: Employee engagement score gauges the level of employee commitment and satisfaction within the organization, often measured through surveys.
  3. Importance: High engagement levels correlate with increased productivity and lower turnover rates. Regularly measuring this score helps HR identify areas for improvement in workplace culture.
  1. Absenteeism Rate
  2. Definition: The absenteeism rate measures the percentage of workdays missed due to unplanned absences.
  3. Importance: High absenteeism can signal employee dissatisfaction or health issues. Monitoring this metric helps HR address underlying problems and improve workplace conditions.
  1. Training Effectiveness
  2. Definition: Training effectiveness assesses the impact of training programs on employee performance and productivity.
  3. Importance: Evaluating training effectiveness ensures that resources are allocated to programs that yield tangible benefits, thereby enhancing employee skills and organizational performance.
  1. Diversity and Inclusion Metrics
  2. Definition: Diversity and inclusion metrics track the representation of various demographic groups within the workforce and the inclusivity of the workplace culture.
  3. Importance: These metrics are essential for fostering a diverse workforce and ensuring equitable opportunities for all employees. They help HR identify gaps and implement targeted initiatives.
  1. Performance Management Metrics
  2. Definition: Performance management metrics evaluate employee performance against set goals and objectives.
  3. Importance: These metrics help HR identify high performers, areas for improvement, and the effectiveness of performance management systems.
  4. Performance can be assessed through regular reviews, goal completion rates, and feedback from peers and supervisors.
  1. Offer Acceptance Rate
  2. Definition: The offer acceptance rate measures the percentage of job offers accepted by candidates.
  3. Importance: A low acceptance rate may indicate issues with the job offer itself, such as salary or benefits, or the organization’s reputation. This metric helps HR refine their offers to attract top talent.
  1. Employee Net Promoter Score (eNPS)
  2. Definition: The Employee Net Promoter Score measures employees’ likelihood to recommend the organization as a place to work.
  3. Importance: A high eNPS indicates strong employee loyalty and satisfaction, while a low score can highlight areas needing improvement.
  4. Employees are typically asked to rate on a scale from 0 to 10, and the eNPS is calculated by subtracting the percentage of detractors (0-6) from promoters (9-10).

HR Department Monthly Metrics Report

Report period: _____________________     Prepared by: ______________________________

MetricDescriptionTotal
# of New Hires  
Cost per Hire(External Costs) + (Internal Costs) / Total # of Hires in a Time Period.  
Time to FillTotal days elapsed to fill requisitions / # Hired 
Turnover Rate(# of separations during month/Avg. # of employees during month) x 100 
Turnover CostTotal of the costs of separation + vacancy + replacement + training 
Vacancy Rate(Total number of vacant positions as of today / Total number of positions
as of today) x 100
 
Vacancy CostTotal of the costs of temporary workers + independent contractors + other outsourcing + overtime – wages and benefits not paid to vacant position(s) 
Absence Rate[(# Days Absent in Month) / (Avg. # employees in Month)
x (# workdays)] x 100
 
Workforce Growth RateEnd of Period Headcount / Beginning of Period Headcount 
Recruiting Cost Ratio(External Costs) + (Internal Costs) / Total of First-Year Compensation of Hires in a Time Period * 100  
 TRAINING 
# Employees Trained(Name of training, if applicable) 
Training
Investment
Total training cost / # of employees 
Training (ROI)( Total Benefit – Total Cost) x 100 
   
 SAFETY 
# of WC Incidents  
Workers’ Compensation Incident Rate(Number of injuries and/or illnesses per 100 FTE ∕ Total hours worked by all employees during the calendar year) x 200,000 
 HR PERFORMANCE 
HR ExpenseHR Expense / Total Operating Costs 
HR Expense per EmployeeHR Costs (include indirect costs, if applicable) / Regular Headcount 

Staff Development:

HRIS Updates:

Employee Recognition and Awards:

HR Staff Accomplishments, Awards, Distinctions:

Social Responsibility:
Policies (implemented/revised/eliminated):
Special Projects:
Action Items for (following month):

SMART Goals Made Simple: Goal-Setting Worksheet
Instructions and Guidelines

What are goals?
Goals are statements of end results expected within a specified period of time.

How are goals defined?
For each goal, describe the end result and indicate quantity, quality, time frame, percentages or other specific measures. Each goal should fit into and support the overall strategy of the business unit. The SMART formula is the most common framework for developing a goal: 

  • Specific
  • Measurable
  • Achievable
  • Relevant
  • Time-Bound

What are some examples of goals?

  • To meet or exceed all financial targets set in the annual business plan.
  • To ensure that all employees understand our strategy and tactics and have incorporated them into the individual goals they have set for themselves and their staff for the year.
  • To complete inspection reports within 30 days from last date of inspection, using the proper format and inspection protocol.
  • To achieve an average time-to-hire completion rate of six weeks.
  • To achieve at least _____ billable hours/year.
  • To consolidate campaign results on a quarterly basis.

When are goals set?
Typically goals are annual and set at the beginning of a fiscal year, which for many organizations coincides with the start of a new calendar year in January.

Who sets the goals?
Goals should be set through mutual agreement between the employee and their supervisor and approved by leadership.

How many goals should there be?
Usually four or more, depending on the nature of the goal. However, each department head may require a minimum number of goals, or they may establish common goals which are to be included on every employee’s worksheet. Professional development goals are also common.

May goals be revised?
Goals may be carried forward from the previous year, revised, added or deleted during the review period as necessary.

Who should have an individual goals worksheet?
Each department head will determine whether certain staff or all staff will be responsible for setting goals.

Individual Goals Worksheet 
Name: ________________________________________
Date: _________________________________________

Position: ______________________________________
Company/Office: ________________________________

Goal 1: [Describe goal]
 
 
 
 
How I will achieve 
 
 
 
 
KPIs
 
 
 
 
 
 
Monthly notes 
 
 
 
 
Quarterly review 
 
 
 
 
Year-end comments 
 
 
 

2026 New York State Passes Bill for Personnel Records & Additional State Information

In late May, 2026 both state chambers passed, (S3460) that would require employers to provide employees with access to their personnel records and impose significant new recordkeeping and disclosure obligations on employers.

If signed by the Governor, the law would take effect 60 days after enactment, leaving employers with a relatively short window to assess and update compliance practices. Under New York’s legislative procedure, the bill could remain pending for many months before being presented to the Governor for approval or veto, and there is no current indication of when that might occur.

Access to Personnel Records 

The bill would amend the Labor Law by adding a new Section 210‑b which would require employers to provide access to their personnel records upon request, subject to several key requirements:

  • Timing: Employers must provide a copy of the personnel record within five (5) business days of receiving a written request;
  • Cost: Records must be provided at no cost to the employee;
  • Scope: The term “personnel records” is broadly defined to include records used, or records that may be used, in connection with an employee’s qualifications for employment, compensation, promotion, transfer, or discipline, including applications, evaluations, and disciplinary documents.

Employers would be prohibited from retaliating against employees who exercise their rights under the statute.

The legislation also would require employers to retain personnel records for at least three years after termination of employment.

The law would not supersede a Collective Bargaining Agreement where it provides substantially similar or greater access to personnel records.

Violations of these requirements would be subject to civil penalties of $500 to $2,500, enforceable by the Attorney General.

Recommendations:

  1. Review of handbook policies and procedures
  2. Review files and access
  3. Train managers and supervisors
  4. Prepare for the law to take effect

Additional Information

Additional State Information:

PA Inspection of Employment Records Law
SHRM Article: Personnel Records Access Legal Obligation Federal Laws & Policies

“In some states, an employee’s request to see his or her file must be in writing: California, Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota and Rhode Island. In other states, the employer may create a policy requiring written requests: Delaware, Illinois, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin.

State laws also vary as to whether employees are allowed to make copies of their records and who must bear the cost of making copies. In Colorado, for example, employees may request copies of their records and employers may require workers to pay reasonable expenses. Pennsylvania employers, however, don’t have to allow copying, but employees are permitted to take notes when viewing their files.

Some state laws set a minimum number of times individuals must be allowed to inspect their files. For instance, in Colorado, current employees are allowed to view their files at least once a year and former employees may take a look at their files once after termination. Minnesota employees can inspect their files once every six months, but former employees can only do so one time within the first year after separation.” (SHRM)

Draft Organizational Policy (varies by State & City):
Employee personnel records are maintained in our human resources department. As required by law, some records pertaining to employees are maintained in separate files relating to medical issues and internal investigations. Employees, or their representative, may request access to their basic personnel file. Depending upon the circumstances, employees may be provided access to records pertaining to internal investigations, with appropriate redactions to protect the rights of others.

All requests for access to your personnel file must be provided in writing to human resources. Upon receipt of your written request, human resources will schedule an appointment for you to view your file during normal office hours. For purposes of this policy, your personnel file includes records related to performance and training as well as other records used for hiring, promotion and disciplinary decisions. It will not include any reference checks, medical records or investigation files. Employees are not permitted to remove any documents from the personnel file but may provide a written response to any document in the personnel file. Written responses will be attached to the original document in the personnel file.

Employees may request copies of documents in their personnel file. Requests for copies must also be made in writing to human resources.

Alaska
In Alaska, all employees are permitted to inspect and duplicate employee personnel documents maintained by their employer. Employees and former employees are allowed to view and copy personnel files and employees may view records during regular business hours under reasonable rules. If the employer requests, then the employee.

California
In the state of California, every current employee, or his or her representative has the right to inspect and receive a copy of their personnel records, maintained by their employer. Once requested in writing by the employee, or an agent of the employee, the employer has up to 30 days to produce the documents unless a later date is agreed upon by the requesting party. All employers are subject to the state personnel file law. Employees have the right to inspect their files at reasonable intervals and check any personnel records relating to performance or to a grievance proceeding. Employees may view records during break or non-work hours. If the records are kept off site or the employer does not make them available at the workplace, the employee must be allowed to view them at the storage location without loss of pay. Employees have the right to copy any documents that employees have signed. The employer can require the employee to pay a reasonable copying cost. See the California website for more information.

Connecticut
Employees have the right to inspect files within seven days after making a request, but not more than twice a year. A former employee has the right to inspect personnel files within 10 business days after making a request. A written request to check files is required. Employers must keep files of former employees for at least one year after termination. Employees may view records during regular business hours in a location at or near the worksite. Employers may require that files be viewed in the presence of employer’s designated official. Employers must provide copies within a reasonable time after receiving an employee’s written request. The request must identify the materials that the employee wants to copy. Employer may charge a fee that is based on the cost of supplying documents. Employees are entitled to a copy of any disciplinary action against the employee within 1 business day after it is imposed. If an employee disagrees with the information in the files, and cannot reach an agreement with employers to remove or correct it, the employee may submit an explanatory written statement. The rebuttal must be maintained as part of the file. See the law for more information.

Delaware
In the state of Delaware, all employers are subject to the state personnel file law. Employees that are current, laid off, with reemployment rights, or on leave of absence may inspect personnel records. An employee’s agent is not entitled to have access to records, unless there is reasonable cause. Employer may limit access to once a year. A written request is only required at employer’s discretion. Records may be viewed during employer’s regular business hours. Employer may require that employees view files on their own time and may also require that files be viewed on the premises and in the presence of a designated official. Employers are not required to allow employees to copy records, however, employees may take notes. If employees disagree with information in the file, and cannot reach an agreement with the employer to remove or correct it, the employee may submit an explanatory written statement. The rebuttal must be maintained as part of the file. See the law for more information.

Florida
Public employees have the right to access their personnel files and request copies of their contents under the Florida Public Records Act, also known as the “Sunshine” law. If a supervisor or department refuses to allow access, the employee can take legal action. 

Private employees do not have an automatic right to access their personnel files, but there are some exceptions: 

  • Union employees: A union contract may grant union employees the right to access their personnel files.
  • Employer policy: The employer may have a policy that allows employees to access their files.

Illinois
In the state of Illinois, employers with 5 or more employees are subject to the state personnel file law. Current employees, or former employees terminated within the past year, are permitted to inspect records twice a year at reasonable intervals, unless a collective bargaining agreement provides otherwise. An employee involved in a current grievance may designate a representative of the union or collective bargaining unit, or other agent, to inspect personnel records that may be relevant to resolving the grievance. An employer must make records available within 7 business days after the employee makes the request. Employers may require the request of certain personnel files be in writing. Records may be viewed during normal business hours at or near worksite or, at employer’s discretion, during nonworking hours at a different location if more convenient for the employee. After reviewing records, employee may get a copy and the employer may charge only for the actual cost of duplication. If employee disagrees with any information on the personnel file and cannot reach an agreement with employer to remove or correct it, employee may submit an explanatory statement. The rebuttal must remain in file with no additional comment by employer. Employers may however, withhold medical records, letters of reference, test documents, staff planning materials, information about a person other than the employee, records subject to a court proceeding, or any records alleging criminal activity. See the Illinois website for more information.

Iowa
In the state of Iowa, all employers with salaried employees or commissioned salespeople are subject to the state personnel file law. Employees may have access to personnel files at a time agreed upon between employers and employees. An employer’s representative may be present. Employers may charge a copying fee for each page that is relevant to a commercial copying service fee. See the law for more information.

Louisiana
In Louisiana, an employee does not have the right to view his or personnel file unless an employee handbook specifically grants that right.  Many other states have laws allowing employees to review their personnel files, although these laws are often subject to limitations. 

Maine
In the state of Maine, all employers are subject to the state personnel file law. Employees can access records ten days within submitting a request. These include employees, former employees or authorized representatives, who all can view and copy personnel files. The request must be in writing. Employees may view records during normal business hours at the location where the files are kept, unless the employer, at its own discretion, arranges a time and place more convenient for the employee. If files are in electronic or any other non-print format, the employer must provide equipment for viewing and copying. Employees are entitled to one free copy of files during each calendar year, including any materials added to the file during that year. Employee must pay for any additional copies. See the law for more information.

Massachusetts
In the state of Massachusetts, employees have the right to review their personnel files within five business days of submitting a request.  Employees may view their records at the workplace during normal business hours and they must be given a copy of their records within five business days of submitting a written request. The request must be in writing. Employer must notify an employee within 10 days of placing in the employee’s personnel record any information to the extent that the information is, has been, or may be used, to negatively affect the employee’s qualification for employment, promotion, transfer, additional compensation, or the possibility that the employee will be subject to disciplinary action. If an employee disagrees with information in the file, and cannot reach an agreement with the employer to remove or correct it, the employee may submit an explanatory written statement. Rebuttals become part of the file. See the law for more information.

Michigan
In the state of Michigan, employers with four or more employees are subject to the state personnel file law. Current or former employees are entitled to review personnel records at reasonable intervals, generally not more than twice a year, unless a collective bargaining agreement provides otherwise. Employees must describe the record(s) they request to review in writing. They may view these records during normal office hours either at or reasonably near the worksite. If these hours would require employees to take time off of work, the employer must provide another reasonable time for review. Employees can copy files and employers may charge only actual cost of duplication. If the employee is unable to view files at the worksite, the employer, upon receipt of a written request, must mail a copy to the employee. If an employee disagrees with information in the file, and cannot reach an agreement with the employer to remove or correct it, the employee may submit an explanatory written statement explaining his or her position. See the law for more information.

Minnesota
Upon written request by an employee, the employer shall provide the employee with an opportunity to review the employee’s personnel record. An employer is not required to provide an employee with an opportunity to review the employee’s personnel record if the employee has reviewed the personnel record during the previous six months; except that, upon separation from employment, an employee may review the employee’s personnel record once each year after separation for as long as the personnel record is maintained.

The employer shall comply with a written request pursuant to subdivision 1 no later than seven working days after receipt of the request if the personnel record is located in this state, or no later than 14 working days after receipt of the request if the personnel record is located outside this state.

With respect to current employees, the personnel record or an accurate copy must be made available for review by the employee during the employer’s normal hours of operation at the employee’s place of employment or other reasonably nearby location, but need not be made available during the employee’s working hours. The employer may require that the review be made in the presence of the employer or the employer’s designee. After the review and upon the employee’s written request, the employer shall provide a copy of the record to the employee.

With respect to employees who are separated from employment, upon the employee’s written request, the employer shall provide a copy of the personnel record to the employee. Providing a copy of the employee’s personnel record to the employee satisfies the employer’s responsibility to allow review.

The employer may not charge a fee for the copy. See the Minnesota website for more information.

Nevada
In the state of Nevada, all employers are subject to the state personnel file law. Any employee who has worked at least 60 days and a former employee, within 60 days of termination, must be given a reasonable opportunity to inspect personnel records. Employees may view records during employer’s normal business hours. Employers may charge only actual cost of providing access and copies. Employees may submit a reasonable written explanation in direct response to any entry in personnel record. These statements must be of reasonable length and employer may specify the format. Employers must also maintain the statement in personnel records. See the law for more information.

New Hampshire
In the state of New Hampshire, all employers are subject to the state personnel file law. Employers must provide employees a reasonable opportunity to inspect personnel records and may charge a fee reasonably related to cost of supplying copies. If an employee disagrees with information in the file, and cannot reach an agreement with the employer to remove or correct it, the employee may submit an explanatory written statement along with supporting evidence. These statements must be maintained as part of personnel file. See the law for more information.

North Carolina
North Carolina law protects the confidentiality of employee personnel files and gives employees the right to review their own files. This law applies to state employees and employees of universities in the state. Here are some details about personnel files in North Carolina: 

All information in a personnel file is confidential, except for certain people: 

  • The employee, applicant, former employee, or their authorized agent can review their entire file, except for letters of reference from before employment 
  • The employee’s supervisor can review their file 
  • A court order or subpoena can allow someone to review a specific part of the file 

Certain information in an employee’s file is open for inspection, including:

  • Name
  • Age
  • Date of employment
  • Terms of employment contract
  • Current position and title
  • Current salary 

See the law for more information.

Oregon
In the state of Oregon, all employers are subject to the state personnel file law. Within 45 days after receipt of a request, employers must provide employees with a reasonable opportunity to inspect personnel records used to determine qualifications for employment, promotion, or additional compensation, termination, or other disciplinary action. Employee may view records at worksite or place of work assignment. Employers must keep records for 60 days after termination of employee. Employees may review records at the workplace or places of work assignment. Employers must provide employees, within 45 days after receipt of request, a certified copy of requested record to current employees. Former employees, if request is made within 60 days of termination, can have certified copies of requested records.

If an employee makes a request 60 days after termination, employers should provide a certified copy of requested records, if employer has the records at the time of request. The employer may charge the amount reasonably calculated to recover actual cost of providing copy.

See the Oregon website for more information.

Pennsylvania
In the state of Pennsylvania, all employers are subject to the state personnel file law. The employer must allow the employee to inspect personnel records at reasonable times. Unless there is reasonable cause, employers may limit the review to once a year by the employee and once a year by employee’s agent.

A written request is required at the employer’s discretion and the records may be viewed during regular business hours at the office where the records are kept. Employee may view records during regular business hours at the office where records are maintained, when there is enough time for employee to complete the review.

Employers may require that employees view records on their own time and may also require that inspection take place on the premises and in the presence of employer’s designated official. Employers are not obligated to permit copying; the employee may take notes, however. The Bureau of Labor Standards may allow employees to place a counter statement into the file, after a petition hearing.

See the law for more information.

Rhode Island
In the state of Rhode Island, all employers are subject to the state personnel file law. Employees need to give employers a seven-day advance notice to access records, excluding weekends and holidays. Employers may limit access to no more than three times a year. Employees can view the records at any reasonable time, other than employee’s work hours. This inspection should take place in the presence of the employer or the employer’s representative. The employee may not make copies or remove any files from place of inspection and the employer may charge a fee reasonably related to supplying copies.
See the law for more information.

South Carolina
Employees in South Carolina have a right to inspect their personnel files. The law applies to all employers in South Carolina and employers who are doing business in the state. 

The request must be made during normal business hours of the organization or entity and must be complied with by the organization or entity within seventy-two hours after receipt of the request.

The employer shall provide the person his file in its entirety with no information removed, edited, expunged, or otherwise altered.
The employer may charge the employee  making the request an amount not to exceed ten dollars to defray the cost of granting access to the personnel file or making copies.
See the law for more information.

Washington
In the state of Washington, all employers are subject to the state personnel file law. Employees may have access to personnel files at least once within a reasonable time after making a request. Employees may also petition annually that the employer review all of the information in the employee’s personnel file and remove any irrelevant or incorrect information.

If there is any irrelevant or incorrect information in the file, employer must remove it. If employee does not agree with employer’s review, employee may have a statement of rebuttal or correction placed in file. Former employee has right of rebuttal for two years after termination.
See the Washington website for more information.

Wisconsin
In the state of Wisconsin, all employers who maintain personnel records are subject to the state personnel file law. Employees or former employees must have the opportunity to review personnel files within seven business days of submitting a request. Access will be permitted twice per calendar year, unless a collective bargaining agreement provides otherwise. Employee involved in a current grievance may designate a representative of the union or collective bargaining unit, or other agent, to inspect records that may be relevant to resolving the grievance.

The employer has discretion to require a written request. Current employees may view the records during normal office hours, either at the worksite or reasonably near the worksite. An employee’s right of inspection includes the right to make or receive copies. If the employer provides copies, they may charge only actual cost of reproduction.

In the event that the employee disagrees with information in the file, and cannot reach an agreement with the employer to remove or correct it, the employee may submit an explanatory written statement. Employer must attach the statement to the disputed portion of the personnel record.

See the Wisconsin website for more information.
https://www.workplacefairness.org/personnel-files-state-law/

The ROI & Value of Executive Coaching and Mentoring

What is Executive Coaching?
Executive coaching is a personalized development process aimed at enhancing an individual’s leadership skills and overall effectiveness. It typically involves one-on-one sessions between a coach and an executive, focusing on specific goals, challenges, and opportunities for growth. Coaches utilize various techniques, including assessments, feedback, and goal setting, to facilitate self-discovery and behavioral change.

Key Features of Executive Coaching

  1. Personalized Approach: Coaching is tailored to the individual’s unique needs, strengths, and areas for improvement.
  2. Goal-Oriented: The process is focused on achieving specific, measurable outcomes that align with both personal and organizational objectives.
  3. Confidential Environment: Coaching provides a safe space for leaders to explore their thoughts, feelings, and challenges without fear of judgment.

What is Mentoring?
Mentoring, on the other hand, is a relationship-based process where a more experienced individual (the mentor) provides guidance, support, and advice to a less experienced individual (the mentee). This relationship often extends beyond professional development to include personal growth and life skills.

Key Features of Mentoring

  1. Long-Term Relationship: Mentoring relationships typically last longer than coaching engagements and can evolve over time.
  2. Knowledge Sharing: Mentors share their experiences, insights, and wisdom, helping mentees navigate their career paths.
  3. Supportive Guidance: Mentors provide encouragement and constructive feedback, fostering a sense of confidence and self-efficacy in mentees.

Benefits of Executive Coaching and Mentoring

  1. Enhanced Leadership Skills

Both coaching and mentoring contribute to the development of essential leadership skills, such as communication, decision-making, and conflict resolution. Leaders who engage in these practices often exhibit improved emotional intelligence, enabling them to connect more effectively with their teams.

  1. Increased Self-Awareness

Through reflective practices and feedback, executives gain a deeper understanding of their strengths and weaknesses. This self-awareness is crucial for personal growth and helps leaders make informed decisions that align with their values and goals.

  1. Improved Performance

Organizations that invest in executive coaching and mentoring often see a significant boost in performance. Leaders equipped with the right tools and insights can drive their teams toward achieving strategic objectives, leading to enhanced productivity and profitability.

  1. Succession Planning

Mentoring plays a critical role in succession planning by preparing the next generation of leaders. By sharing knowledge and experiences, mentors help mentees develop the skills necessary to take on leadership roles in the future.

  1. Enhanced Employee Engagement

When leaders are supported through coaching and mentoring, they are more likely to create a positive work environment. Engaged leaders foster engaged teams, leading to higher morale, lower turnover rates, and increased job satisfaction.

The Process of Executive Coaching and Mentoring
Executive Coaching Process

  1. Assessment: The coaching process often begins with assessments to identify strengths, weaknesses, and areas for development.
  2. Goal Setting: Together, the coach and executive establish clear, achievable goals.
  3. Action Planning: The coach helps the executive develop a plan to reach their goals, including specific actions and timelines.
  4. Implementation: The executive works on the agreed-upon actions, with the coach providing ongoing support and feedback.
  5. Evaluation: Progress is regularly reviewed to ensure that the coaching is effective and goals are being met.

Mentoring Process

  1. Matching: Organizations typically match mentors and mentees based on shared interests, goals, and experiences.
  2. Establishing Goals: The mentor and mentee collaboratively set goals for their relationship, focusing on areas of development.
  3. Regular Meetings: Mentoring relationships thrive on consistent communication, with regular meetings to discuss progress and challenges.
  4. Feedback and Reflection: Mentors provide feedback and encourage mentees to reflect on their experiences and learning.
  5. Closure: As the mentee grows, the relationship may evolve or conclude, with both parties reflecting on their journey.

Coaching and/or mentoring can add tremendous value to your organization and the career path of leadership.  Work with a coach/mentor that understands the specific needs of your organization and the leader.  Measure results and evolve the process.

2026 Independent Contractor Considerations

Questions to Consider:
 
Behavioral control

  • Instructions: An employee is given instructions on how, when, and where to perform the work, while a contractor is not.
  • Training: The hiring entity does not train an independent contractor on how to do their job; the contractor uses their own methods.
  • Personal services: The contractor usually has the right to hire others to do the work, whereas an employee typically must perform the services personally. 

Financial control

  • Investment: An independent contractor often has a significant investment in tools, equipment, or a business, while an employee does not.
  • Expenses: An independent contractor may have unreimbursed business expenses, while an employee’s expenses are often reimbursed.
  • Opportunity for profit or loss: A contractor’s opportunity to earn a profit or incur a loss based on their managerial skill is a key indicator of independence.
  • Payment: Contractors are often paid a flat fee for a job, while employees are usually paid an hourly or salary wage. 

Type of relationship

  • Permanency: The relationship is typically less permanent for an independent contractor than for an employee.
  • Integration: The work performed by an independent contractor is often not an integral part of the hiring company’s main business activities.
  • Benefits: Independent contractors do not receive employee-type benefits like health insurance or vacation pay.
  • Written contract: A written agreement stating the worker is an independent contractor is considered, but it is not the only factor. 

https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/fact-sheets/13-flsa-employment-relationship

“Governor Hochul signed legislation on November 22, 2023, creating protections for independent contractors that are very similar to the requirements of New York City’s Freelance Isn’t Free Act.

The law creates a new section of the New York Labor Law, 191-D, and sets forth wage and job protections for freelance workers in New York State. The law defines “freelance worker” as any person or an organization composed of only one person (in other words, an individual contractor’s corporation) hired as an independent contractor for at least $800. It excludes construction contractors.

The law requires companies who enter into covered agreements with freelance workers to reduce the terms of the agreement to writing, provide a written copy of the contract to the freelance worker, and include the following minimum information in the contract:

  • The name and mailing address of both the hiring party and freelance worker
  • An itemization of all services to be provided by the freelance worker, the value of these services, and the rate and method of compensation
  • The date on which the hiring party must pay the contracted compensation or the mechanism by which such date will be determined (if this provision is not included, then payment must be made no later than 30 days after the completion of the freelance worker’s services)
  • The date by which the freelance worker must submit a list of all services rendered to meet any payment processing deadline of the hiring party

The hiring party is required to keep contracts for at least six years. The bill provides that the failure to produce a freelancer contract upon request by the NY DOL shall give rise to a presumption that the terms that the freelance worker has presented are the agreed upon terms. The law also requires the NY DOL to create template contracts, although companies would not be prohibited from creating or continuing to use their own.

Under the law, any freelance worker can file a confidential complaint with the NY DOL. The bill expressly provides that failure of a hiring party to keep adequate records can expose them to penalties and, in the absence of any records, “the hiring party…shall bear the burden of proving that the complaining employee was paid in accordance with this section.” The bill also gives freelance workers protection from intimidation, harassment, or discrimination for exercising their rights under the law.

Finally, the law provides a private right of action and six-year statute of limitations, except for claims regarding failure to provide a compliant written contract, which have a two-year statute of limitations and require a plaintiff to demonstrate they requested a written contract before the work began. Statutory damages for failing to provide a written contract are set at $250. Liquidated damages and attorney fees are available for a plaintiff who prevails on claims regarding failure to timely pay for services owed or retaliation.

The law takes effect on May 20, 2024, and applies only to contracts entered into on or after that date.” (Morgan Lewis)

https://www.morganlewis.com/pubs/2023/12/new-york-state-year-end-legislative-developments-for-employers-to-know

https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/new-york-state-2024-employment-law-6603981/

Additional Freelance Legal Protections by State & City

https://freelancerfiles.com/blogs/news/5-states-cities-are-now-regulating-freelance-work-in-the-us-here-s-what-you-need-to-know

Federal Updates:

The federal article below continues to evolve, expect more changes defining independent contractors at the FEDERAL DOL with the Trump Administration.

Trump DOL Pauses Biden Independent Contractor Rule Defense

The U.S. Department of Labor announced Tuesday a final rule revising its interpretation of the Fair Labor Standards Act’s classification provision to determine whether a worker may be considered an independent contractor.

The final rule largely tracks the agency’s October 2022 proposed rule. It retains the multifactor, “totality-of-the-circumstances” framework for analyzing independent contractors’ status included in that proposal.
Under this framework, DOL will consider six non exhaustive factors when examining the relationship between a worker and a potential employer:

  1. Worker’s opportunity for profit or loss.
  2. Investments made by the worker and the employer.
  3. Degree of permanence of the work relationship.
  4. Nature and degree of control over performance of the work.
  5. Extent to which the work performed is an integral part of the employer’s business.
  6. Use of the worker’s skill and initiative.

The rule will be published in the Federal Register on Wednesday, Jan. 10, and is slated to take effect March 11, officials said. (HR Dive)

Current Independent Factor Test

“An employment relationship under the FLSA must be distinguished from a strictly contractual one. Such a relationship must exist for any provision of the FLSA to apply to any person engaged in work which may otherwise be subject to the Act. In the application of the FLSA an employee, as distinguished from a person who is engaged in a business of his or her own, is one who, as a matter of economic reality, follows the usual path of an employee and is dependent on the business which he or she serves. The employer-employee relationship under the FLSA is tested by “economic reality” rather than “technical concepts.” It is not determined by the common law standards relating to master and servant.

The U.S. Supreme Court has on a number of occasions indicated that there is no single rule or test for determining whether an individual is an independent contractor or an employee for purposes of the FLSA. The Court has held that it is the total activity or situation which controls. Among the factors which the Court has considered significant are:

  1. The extent to which the services rendered are an integral part of the principal’s business.
  2. The permanency of the relationship.
  3. The amount of the alleged contractor’s investment in facilities and equipment.
  4. The nature and degree of control by the principal.
  5. The alleged contractor’s opportunities for profit and loss.
  6. The amount of initiative, judgment, or foresight in open market competition with others required for the success of the claimed independent contractor.
  7. The degree of independent business organization and operation.

There are certain factors which are immaterial in determining whether there is an employment relationship. Such facts as the place where work is performed, the absence of a formal employment agreement, or whether an alleged independent contractor is licensed by State/local government are not considered to have a bearing on determinations as to whether there is an employment relationship. Additionally, the Supreme Court has held that the time or mode of pay does not control the determination of employee status.

Exempt and nonexempt, hourly, salaried, and salaried nonexempt are definitions that most of us know and currently use to classify the positions in our organizations.  We know that we must classify individuals in an exempt or nonexempt (overtime eligible) position for payroll, overtime and reporting purposes.  There are numerous definitions to define exempt level positions under the current FLSA (federal) regulations. 

Remember that the salary threshold in New York State varies for executive and administrative professionals, when comparing with the federal law.  As leaders, we need to ensure our classifications for each position within our organizations are accurate and our workforce is paid correctly for work performed and hours worked.”

(https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/fact-sheets/13-flsa-employment-relationship)

https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/fact-sheets/13-flsa-employment-relationship

National Labor Relations Board June 2023 Ruling
“A new ruling from the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) alters the standard employers must use to determine whether someone qualifies as an independent contractor.

In the June 13 ruling, the board concluded that the makeup artists, wig artists and hairstylists who work at the Atlanta Opera are employees, not independent contractors. The workers had filed an election petition with the board, seeking union representation.

The NLRB rejected the previous ruling in SuperShuttle that entrepreneurial opportunity for gain or loss should be the animating principle of the independent contractor test. Instead, it said entrepreneurial opportunity should be taken into account alongside a list of traditional common-law factors.

Those factors include:

  • The extent of control the employer exercises over the details of the work.
  • Whether the work is usually done under the direction of the employer or without supervision.
  • Whether the worker is engaged in a distinct occupation or business.
  • How much skill is required in the particular occupation.
  • Whether the employer supplies the tools and the place of work.
  • The length of time for which the worker is employed.
  • The method of payment, whether by the hour or by the job.
  • Whether the work is a part of the regular business of the employer.

“Applying this clear standard will ensure that workers who seek to organize or exercise their rights under the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) are not improperly excluded from its protections,” said NLRB Chairman Lauren McFerran.

The SuperShuttle ruling “cannot be squared with board precedent, with the common law, or with Supreme Court precedent,” the NLRB wrote in its opinion.

In this case, the creative workers did not have true entrepreneurial opportunity because in reality there was no other opera across town that they could take their talents to, according to David Korn, an attorney with Phelps Dunbar in New Orleans.

“Hypothetical opportunity should not be considered,” said James Evans, an attorney with Alston Bird in Los Angeles.

The new ruling “is designed and intended to make it much more difficult for employers to classify workers as independent contractors and therefore avoid the potential for those workers to organize,” said Jason Reisman, an attorney with Blank Rome in Philadelphia. “This new decision will serve potentially as a solid deterrent for many employers and create doubt for others, or at least make them think twice and re-evaluate how and how often they utilize independent contractors.”

In light of the NLRB decision, “it might be time to reevaluate what our written agreement looks like” for independent contractors and how it’s working in practice, said David Pryzbylski, an attorney with Barnes & Thornburg in Indianapolis. “Anybody using independent contractors needs to take notice of this. The gig economy is top of mind.”

“Employers should know it is not enough to rely upon the method of payment or industry past practices and norms to classify and treat service providers as independent contractors,” said Michael Gotzler, an attorney with Littler in Madison, Wis. “The legal risks and attendant financial exposure are too great nowadays for any business to ignore this evolving area of law.”

However, Todd Lebowitz, an attorney with BakerHostetler in Cleveland said, “This is a low-impact decision. More than anything else, it just reflects that different board members have different perspectives when applying the same common-law test, just like different judges have different perspectives when applying the same test,”

How Employees Differ from Independent Contractors
Under federal law, employees may be entitled to union rights, minimum wage, overtime pay and other benefits. Independent contractors are not entitled to such benefits, but they generally have more flexibility to set their own schedules and work for multiple companies.

Contractors can’t form unions and can’t file unfair labor practice charges with the NLRB, Pryzbylski said.

SHRM filed a friend-of-the-court brief with the NLRB in favor of keeping the SuperShuttle standard. “In order to recruit and retain the best talent, especially during these challenging economic times, [businesses] must offer a myriad of work relationship options that provide the 21st-century worker the autonomy necessary to make the best decisions for them and their families. To that end, the availability of independent work is not only valuable to workers, but necessary for businesses to compete in today’s global marketplace,” SHRM stated, noting that almost 50 percent of Generation Z and 44 percent of Millennials engage in some form of independent work.” (SHRM)


What Is the Most Common Test for Independent Contractors?The ABC test is the most common test used for determining whether someone is an independent contractor. If an employee meets all three of these conditions, they are considered to be an independent contractor.

Conditions of the ABC test:

  • Condition A — The individual must be free from the direction and control of the hiring entity. This includes the execution of the work and how the employee is supervised.
  • Condition B — Second, the independent contractor has to perform work that is considered to be outside the scope of the hiring entity’s business. For example, a software company may hire someone to fix its plumbing system.
  • Condition C — Finally, the worker must be engaged in an independently established occupation, business, or trade that is the same as the work they are performing.

Condition B is particularly challenging for many contractors to meet and is often criticized as overly restrictive. For example, a self-employed freelance journalist hired by a magazine or website to write an article would be unable to meet Condition B because their line of work is the same as that of the hiring company: producing written content. The same would apply to many temporary workers, including a musician hired to fill in for an unavailable band member, a carpenter hired to help a construction firm build a house, or a baker hired to help a caterer with a particularly large event.

To alleviate for Condition B’s unintentional heavy-handedness, many states pass additional laws, such as California‘s AB 2257, giving certain professions exemptions from Condition B (or the ABC test as a whole).

Common Law Rules for independent contractors:

States that do not use the ABC test typically use the similar Common Law Rules as outlined by the US Internal Revenue Service (IRS). The answers to the common law questions help determine if a worker is considered an independent contractor or a full employee.

  1. Behavioral control: Does the hiring company control the worker and/or the methods they use to complete the work?
  2. Financial control: Does the hiring company control aspects of the worker’s compensation, such as how they are paid, if expenses are reimbursed, and who furnishes needed supplies?
  3. Relational control: Does the hiring company offer the worker benefits such as insurance or vacation pay? Is the work being done part of the hiring company’s main business? Is the working relationship ongoing?

What States Use the ABC Test?

There are several states that commonly use the ABC test to decide whether someone is an independent contractor. These include AlaskaArkansas, California, ConnecticutDelawareGeorgiaHawaiiIllinoisIndianaKansasLouisianaMaineMarylandMassachusettsNebraskaNevadaNew HampshireNew JerseyNew MexicoOhioOregonRhode IslandTennesseeUtahVermontWashington, and West Virginia. Anyone working as an independent contractor in these states must pass the ABC test if they want to be classified as such.

Any other states generally have requirements that are very similar, but there may be a few differences. For example, several states require the contractor to meet only conditions A and C of the ABC test or utilize Common Law Rules instead.

https://worldpopulationreview.com/state-rankings/independent-contractor-laws-by-state

Employee or Independent Contractor?
The most basic question about the employment relationship is whether a worker is, in fact, an employee or an independent contractor. As with so many employment law issues, the answer is it depends. In this case, it depends on who is asking: the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL), a workers’ compensation hearing officer and so on. Even courts have admitted that the distinction is not always clear. Regardless of what the employer calls the worker; contractor, freelancer, consultant or gig worker, the same principles apply. SeeNavigating Employment Law in the Gig Economy.

Employee status triggers employer obligations under various federal and state laws that do not apply to independent contractors, and the responsibility for classifying a worker correctly falls squarely on the employer. HR professionals must understand the practical and legal differences between employees and independent contractors.

No bright-line test exists to determine when a worker should be classified as an employee rather than as an independent contractor. However, a wealth of information is readily available to help organizations make the necessary case-by-case determinations. Once the decision has been made to meet a staffing need through independent contractors, organizations can take several practical steps to manage independent contractors effectively.

SeeBLS: Contingent and Alternative Employment Arrangements Summary and Gigs Are the Future of Work: A Q&A with Sarah Kessler.

How to Classify Properly
No legal test applies in every situation when deciding to classify a worker as an independent contractor. For example, the IRS and DOL use different, although similar, analytical frameworks. In fact, the multiplicity of tests defining independent contractor status applied across federal and state laws makes it possible for a worker to be classified as an independent contractor under one law but as an employee under another.

To minimize legal risk, employers are well-advised to ensure that classification as an independent contractor would satisfy every test that may be applicable where the organization does business.

TESTS FOR INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR STATUS
Various federal government agencies and some states have their own tests to determine independent contractor status.

DOL. According to the DOL’s Fact Sheet 13: Employment Relationship Under the Fair Labor Standards Act, “The U.S. Supreme Court has on a number of occasions indicated that there is no single rule or test for determining whether an individual is an independent contractor or an employee for purposes of the FLSA. The Court has held that it is the total activity or situation which controls.” The following factors have been considered significant in determining independent contractor classification:

  • The extent to which the services rendered are an integral part of the principal’s business.
  • The permanency of the relationship.
  • The amount of the alleged contractor’s investment in facilities and equipment.
  • The nature and degree of control by the principal.
  • The alleged contractor’s opportunities for profit and loss.
  • The amount of initiative, judgment, or foresight in open market competition with others required for the success of the claimed independent contractor.
  • The degree of independent business organization and operation.

SeeMisclassification of Employees as Independent Contractors and DOL Issues Guidance on Independent Contractors.

Additionally, some statutes enforced by the DOL, such as the federal Service Contract Act, contain their own definitions of what constitutes an employee for purposes of the statute. SeeEmployee coverage does not depend on form of employment contract.

IRS. As reflected in Section 2 of its Publication 15-A: Employer’s Supplemental Tax Guide, the IRS now looks at 11 factors (rather than the previous 20 factors) within three areas:

  • Behavioral: Does the company control or have the right to control what the worker does and how the worker does his or her job?
  • Financial: Are the business aspects of the worker’s job controlled by the payer? (These include such considerations as how the worker is paid, whether expenses are reimbursed, who provides tools/supplies, etc.)
  • Type of Relationship: Are there written contracts or employee-type benefits (e.g., pension plan, insurance, vacation pay, etc.)? Will the relationship continue, and is the work performed a key aspect of the business?

SeeIndependent Contractor (Self-Employed) or Employee?

Organizations or individuals can request an official determination of a worker’s status under the IRS test by filing IRS Form SS-8.

Workers’ compensation laws. The test for independent contractor status under workers’ compensation laws varies from state to state. To find out more about the workers’ compensation test in a given state, employers may contact the state department of industrial relations or the state labor department. See State Workers’ Compensation Officials.

State laws. Some states may have different or more-restrictive independent contractor classification rules. Several states, such as California, use their own three-factor test, also known as an “ABC” test, where three main criteria must be met. Each employer should check the laws in the states in which they wish to hire independent contractors to ensure compliance. SeeHow do I know if an individual is considered an employee or independent contractor in California?

Legal Ramifications of Misclassification
Classifying a gig worker as an independent contractor should always be an informed and bona fide business decision, not a subterfuge to avoid the employer’s obligations to employees. Misclassification of an individual as an independent contractor can give rise to a variety of liabilities. SeeIndependent-Contractor Classifications May Need to Be Reviewed.

If the purported independent contractor arrangement is between two organizations, that is, between the organization receiving the services and the organization that actually engages the workers, there is a risk of being found to be a joint employer—a legal relationship in which both client and contractor can be liable for violations of employment laws. SeeHow to Minimize Staffing Agency Snags.

TAX CONSEQUENCES
Employers are required to withhold income taxes based on information employees provide on IRS Form W-4. If an employer fails to withhold income taxes on behalf of a worker improperly classified as an independent contractor, and the individual has failed to pay the taxes, the employer may be liable for federal or state taxes that were required to be withheld but were not.

Furthermore, independent contractors are not eligible to receive tax-free benefits from the organization. If the company chooses to offer health care benefits to an independent contractor, the contractor must pay income taxes on the value of the benefit. If the company includes an independent contractor in its defined benefit pension plan, it risks losing the tax-exempt status of the plan. SeeWhat Benefits Can Companies Offer Gig Workers?

Additionally, beginning with tax year 2020, employers must use Form 1099-NEC to report nonemployee compensation rather than the 1099-MISC. SeeWhat is the difference between IRS Form 1099-NEC and Form 1099-MISC?

EMPLOYEE BENEFITS OBLIGATIONS
In Vizcaino v. Microsoft Corporation, the court found that Microsoft had mischaracterized certain workers as independent contractors and freelancers. Although the workers had been hired for specific projects, some continued to work on successive projects for several years. They were fully integrated into Microsoft’s workforce, and worked onsite and on work teams along with Microsoft’s regular employees. They also shared the same supervisors, performed identical functions and worked the same core hours as regular employees. Microsoft provided them with admittance card keys, office equipment and supplies. However, as independent contractors, these workers were not eligible for the same employee benefits that Microsoft’s regular employees received. Microsoft reached a settlement for $96.89 million and was subsequently assessed approximately $27.13 million in attorney fees and costs.

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION
A misclassified gig worker can result in the supposed employer being held liable for on-the-job injuries outside the protections of the workers’ compensation system, and for penalties as well.

UNEMPLOYMENT COMPENSATION
A worker may file a claim for unemployment compensation and be granted benefits if the unemployment agency believes that the worker was misclassified as an independent contractor. If the organization misclassified the worker, it may be liable for penalties and interest in addition to unpaid unemployment insurance premiums. SeeNew York Uber Drivers Can Collect Unemployment Benefits.

WAGE AND HOUR LIABILITY
The widespread use of gig workers invites the scrutiny of plaintiffs’ attorneys who may be eager to bring a class- or collective-action suit for unpaid overtime or minimum wage violations under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) or state wage and hour laws. SeeWage and Hour Class Actions Can Cost Employers Millions.

VICARIOUS LIABILITY
An employer may incur liability for wrongful acts of a worker who it has mistakenly classified as an independent contractor. Even when an individual has been correctly classified as an independent contractor, an employer may still be liable for work that is considered “inherently dangerous activity,” or if the employer exercises control over the work or the activity that caused harm to a third party. (SHRM)

Independent Contractor Tax Information
The 1099-MISC form has been used in the past to report certain payments, including nonemployee compensation (NEC), to the IRS. Beginning with tax year 2020, the 1099-MISC has been redesigned due to the creation of Form 1099-NEC. Employers will no longer report nonemployee compensation, such as payments to independent contractors, on Form 1099-MISC.

Form 1099-NEC
Beginning with tax year 2020, employers must use Form 1099-NEC to report nonemployee compensation. If the following four conditions are met, you must generally report a payment as nonemployee compensation:

  1. You made the payment to someone who is not your employee.
  2. You made the payment for services rendered in the course of your trade or business (including government agencies and nonprofit organizations).
  3. You made the payment to an individual, a partnership, an estate or, in some cases, a corporation.
  4. You made payments to the payee of at least $600 during the year.

Common examples of nonemployee compensation include payments to independent contractors, fees paid for professional services such as of attorneys and accountants, and commissions paid to nonemployee salespersons that are subject to repayment but not repaid during the calendar year.

Employers are required to furnish Form 1099-NEC to the payee and file with the IRS by January 31 (February 1 in 2021, since January 31 falls on a Sunday).

Form 1099-NEC example: 


Form 1099-MISC
According to the IRS, beginning with tax year 2020, you should file Form 1099-MISC for each person to whom you have paid the following in the course of your business during the year:

  • At least $10 in royalties or broker payments in lieu of dividends or tax-exempt interest.
  • At least $600 in the following:
    • Rents.
    • Prizes and awards.
    • Other income payments.
    • Generally, cash from a notional principal contract to an individual, a partnership or an estate.
    • Any fishing boat proceeds.
    • Medical and health care payments.
    • Crop insurance proceeds.
    • Payments to an attorney.
    • Section 409A deferrals.
    • Nonqualified deferred compensation.

Employers must furnish the Form 1099-MISC to the recipient by January 31 and file with the IRS by February 28 (March 31 if filing electronically). For 2021, the due dates are February 1 to the recipient and March 1 to the IRS.
 
For detailed instructions and examples for both forms, see Instructions for Forms 1099-MISC and 1099‑NEC.
 
IRS Independent Contractor Website
 
https://www.irs.gov/forms-pubs/about-form-w-9
 
Checklist: Utilizing Independent Contractors
Contract Development
☐ Review Department of Labor and IRS criteria to ensure an independent contractor relationship.
☐ Use Form SS-8 for IRS determination of independent contractor status if unclear and the determination cannot be made by the business.
☐ Develop a written agreement with an assigned specific scope of work for a specific duration.
☐ Do not have a contractor complete an employment application.
☐ Require the contractor to supply his or her own workers’ compensation and liability insurance.
☐ Require the contractor to supply his or her own equipment and tools.
☐ Establish invoicing requirements and payment dates.
☐ Do not pay contractor expenses; expenses should be built into the contract for the cost of the entire job.
☐ Do not provide continuing education training. The company may provide training specific to the assignment or company procedures.
☐ Do not have contractors perform similar work of employees or perform routine work.
☐ Contractor work should not be close to core business operations and therefore considered employee-type work.  
☐ Require documentation demonstrating an independent contractor relationship, such as a copy of business or professional license, copy of insurance certificates, copies of the independent contractor’s advertising, and copy of the contractor’s business card and stationery. 
 
Contract Signed; Contractor Work to Begin
☐ Require the contractor complete Form W-9, Request for Taxpayer Identification Number and Certification. This form can be used to request the correct name and taxpayer identification number, or TIN, of the worker. A TIN may be either a Social Security number (SSN) or an employer identification number (EIN).
☐ Do not complete an I-9 form.
☐ Do not pay contractors from a payroll account.
☐ Do not provide an employee handbook.
☐ Do not allow independent contractors to enroll in any company-sponsored benefit plans or offer other benefits.
☐ Do not invite or permit contractors to attend company parties or special events intended for employees.
☐ Do not issue company business cards or employee ID badges to contractors.
☐ Restrict contractor participation in projects or department meetings.
☐ Do not give independent contractors authority for hiring, disciplinary action or termination decisions.
☐ Do not require the contractor to work “full time” or have set hours. Contractors should control when and how they work.
☐ Do not conduct performance evaluations similar to employee evaluations. Companies should require deadlines and results and can require contractors to follow job and company rules.
 
Contract Work in Progress (1 month to end of contract)
☐ Periodically review the contract and assigned scope of work to ensure contractor is working within the contract scope and maintaining independent contractor status.
☐ Confirm with company contact(s) that the contractor has not been provided additional duties or benefits outside the scope of the contract or anything else that would jeopardize independent contractor status.
☐ Retain records of all transactions with the contractor, such as the contractor’s invoices for billing.

Ongoing
☐ Review IRS criteria to ensure company is maintaining an independent contractor relationship.
☐ Confirm W-9 is on record and retained for four years.
☐ Send form 1099-NEC each year for any contractor (e.g., attorney, accountant, consultant) paid $600 or more for services provided during the year.
☐ Review W-9 Record Retention Schedule to purge unneeded files.
 Retain W-9 for four years for future reference in case of any questions from the worker or the IRS. 
☐ Destroy records that have met the retention requirements unless employer is involved in a dispute that has not yet been resolved.
 
Draft Independent Contractor Agreement (Review State or Local Law)
This independent contractor agreement (Agreement) is entered into this ____ day of ______________, 20__, by and between ______________(Corporation), and _______________________________, an independent contractor (Contractor), in consideration of the mutual promises made herein, as follows:

Term of Agreement
This Agreement will become effective on the ______ day of _______________, 20__, and will continue in effect until: ________, 20__.

Services to be Rendered by Contractor
Contractor agrees to provide the following services:
____________________________________________________________________________
 
Method of Performing Services:
Contractor will determine the method, details, and means of performing the above-described services, including the determination of the need for and hiring of assistants at the Contractor’s own expense. The Corporation may not control, direct or otherwise supervise Contractor’s assistants or employees in the performance of those services.

Compensation:
In consideration for the services to be performed by Contractor, Corporation agrees to pay Contractor the sum of ________________________ dollars ($__________), upon completion of the work to be performed.

Tools and Instruments:
Contractor will supply all tools, equipment and supplies required to perform the services under this Agreement.

Workers Compensation:
Contractor agrees to provide workers’ compensation insurance for Contractor’s employees and agents and agrees to hold harmless and indemnify Corporation for any and all claims arising out of any injury, disability, or death of any of Contractor’s employees or agents.

Insurance:
Contractor agrees to maintain a policy of insurance in the minimum amount of _________________ Dollars ($__________) to cover any negligent acts committed by Contractor or Contractor’s employees or agents during the performance of any duties under this Agreement. Contractor further agrees to hold Corporation free and harmless from any and all claims arising from any such negligent act or omission.

Obligations of Corporation
Corporation agrees to meet the terms of all reasonable requests of Contractor necessary to the performance of Contractor’s duties under this Agreement.

Assignment:
Neither this Agreement nor any duties or obligations under this Agreement may be assigned by Corporation or Contractor without the prior written consent of Contractor and Corporation.

Termination of Agreement:
Notwithstanding any other provisions of this Agreement, either party hereto may terminate this Agreement at any time by giving ________ days written notice to the other party.

General Provisions
Notices:
Any notices to be given hereunder by either party to the other may be made either by personal delivery or by mail, registered or certified, postage prepaid with return receipt requested. Mailed notices shall be addressed to the parties at the following addresses:

Corporation: ______________________________________________________________
Contractor: _______________________________________________________________
Each party may change the above address by written notice in accordance with this paragraph. Notices delivered personally shall be deemed communicated as of the date of actual receipt; mailed notices shall be deemed communicated as of three (3) days after the date of mailing.

Entire Agreement:
This Agreement supersedes any and all other agreements, either oral or in writing, between the parties hereto with respect to the performance of services by Contractor for Corporation and contains all of the covenants and agreements between the parties with respect to the rendering of such services in any manner whatsoever. Each party to this Agreement acknowledges that no representations, inducements, promises or agreements, orally or otherwise, have been made by any party, or anyone acting on behalf of any party, which are not embodied herein, and that no other agreement, statement, or promise not contained in this Agreement shall be valid or binding. Any modification of this Agreement will be effective only if it is in writing signed by the party to be charged.

Partial Invalidity:
If any provision of this Agreement is held by a court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid, void or unenforceable, the remaining provisions shall nevertheless continue in full force without being impaired or invalidated in any way.

Governing Law:
This Agreement shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the laws of the State of ________________________________.
 
Corporation, by _____________________                Date______________________________
 
Contractor, by ______________________                Date ______________________________
 

Invoice Template
[ADD LOGO/IMAGE] HOURLY CONTRACTOR
INVOICE
 
DETAILS
DATE: 2/1/2025
INVOICE NO. [#]
FROM BILL TO
[COMPANY NAME] [COMPANY NAME]
[ATTN] [ATTN]
[STREET ADDRESS] [STREET ADDRESS]
[CITY, STATE, ZIP CODE] [CITY, STATE, ZIP CODE]
[PHONE] [PHONE]
[E-MAIL] [E-MAIL]
 
DESCRIPTION QUANTITY UNIT PRICE AMOUNT ($)
 
NOTES: ___________________________________________
__________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
 
SUBTOTAL
DISCOUNT
TAX / VAT
TOTAL
 
THANK YOU FOR YOUR BUSINESS

2026 Federal Government Cannabis Reclassification – Employer Considerations & Additional State Information

The reclassification of cannabis from a Schedule I to a Schedule III drug will not legalize recreational use or immediately change most workplace drug policies, but it introduces key considerations for employers, particularly regarding medical accommodations, drug testing, and federal compliance. 

Key Impacts for Employers

  • No Immediate Legalization or Mandate to Change Policies: Rescheduling does not equate to full federal legalization of marijuana; it remains a controlled substance. Employers are generally not required to change their existing drug testing or zero-tolerance policies, especially in safety-sensitive industries.
  • Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and Accommodations: Because Schedule III drugs have a federally recognized medical use, medical cannabis may potentially qualify as a “reasonable accommodation” under the ADA in some circumstances. This will likely be a complex legal area, requiring employers to evaluate HR policies to manage potential disability claims.
  • Safety-Sensitive Positions: The Department of Transportation (DOT) has stated that rescheduling will not affect its mandatory drug testing rules. Employees in safety-sensitive positions (e.g., truck drivers, pilots, heavy machinery operators) will continue to be subject to federal testing requirements and zero-tolerance rules for THC.
  • State Law Conflicts: The federal change will reduce the conflict between federal and state medical cannabis laws. However, employers must still navigate a complex and evolving patchwork of state and local laws, many of which restrict or prohibit drug testing for marijuana, particularly for off-duty use in non-safety-sensitive roles.
  • Focus on Impairment: Without a reliable, federally recognized test for current marijuana impairment (unlike alcohol), zero-tolerance policies may persist. Employers are advised to train supervisors on recognizing impairment and addressing it properly.
  • Confidentiality: Information related to an employee’s medical cannabis use must be treated as confidential health information, requiring extra safeguards.
  • Cannabis Businesses: Companies within the state-legal cannabis industry will see significant financial relief as they will no longer be subject to the IRS Section 280E tax code, which previously barred them from deducting normal business expenses. This also means better access to banking services and increased opportunities for research. 
     

Over the past decade we have seen significant changes throughout the country at the local and state level related to medicinal and recreational marijuana, with the majority of states legalizing some form of THC or cannabis. Marijuana is still illegal at the federal level, which governs in the Department of Transportation rules and regulations for many positions across the country. With the president recently pardoning federal marijuana-related misdemeanors, HR professionals need to ensure we embrace not only the changes laws and regulations, but the changing attitudes towards recreational and medicinal marijuana use.

New York State Recreational Marijuana Q&A PDF

States with Potential 2026 Marijuana Proposals

The status of these initiatives is subject to change as signature gathering and legal reviews are ongoing. 

Active Legalization Efforts

  • Florida: The “Smart & Safe Florida” campaign is pushing a constitutional amendment to legalize adult-use marijuana for individuals 21 and older. The proposal would allow adults to possess up to 2 ounces of cannabis flower and prohibits public smoking and youth-focused marketing. The campaign has gathered enough signatures to trigger a State Supreme Court review and needs over 880,000 total valid signatures by February 2026 to make the ballot.
  • Idaho: Two citizen initiatives may appear on the ballot:
    • One initiative would create a legal system for medical marijuana for qualifying conditions.
    • A second initiative aims to decriminalize the possession and use of marijuana for all purposes for people aged 21 and older.
  • Nebraska: An initiative is in progress to establish a right to the recreational use of marijuana for individuals 21 years of age or older.
  • Oklahoma: A campaign is underway to put “State Question 837” on the ballot, which would legalize recreational marijuana, allow home cultivation of up to six plants, and create a licensed retail market.
  • Wisconsin: The governor has indicated that if Democrats take control of the legislature, they can “finally” legalize marijuana through the legislative process. 

Efforts to Restrict or Repeal Laws

  • Idaho: The Idaho Legislature has already placed a measure on the ballot (HJR 4) that would amend the state constitution to give only the Legislature the authority to legalize marijuana, narcotics, or other psychoactive substances, effectively removing the power of citizen-initiated measures.
  • Massachusetts: A proposed initiative seeks to repeal the majority of a 2016 initiative that legalized recreational marijuana sales, making retail sales illegal while still allowing possession of up to one ounce.
  • Maine: Anti-drug activists are also pursuing a ballot initiative to repeal the state’s legal cannabis market. 

By State

  • Medicinal Use & ADA:    Medical marijuana is legalized in the majority of the states throughout the country. Medical providers can and do prescribe marijuana for medicinal use. We should fully understand reasonable accommodation, essential functions, and additional considerations under the American with Disabilities Act, along with other local and state laws and regulations. 
  • Drug Testing: Certain states and cities have now banned preemployment drug testing for THC for many positions in the state or locale. Ensure you have a clear understanding of any evolving laws and regulations. Also consider DOT regulations, at times you might have separate drug testing policies for DOT and non-DOT employees in the same organizations. Expectations and policies should be communicated. 
  • Criminal Background Checks:  Laws and regulations continue to evolve on criminal background checks, related to prior charges for marijuana related crimes. This includes second chance legislation. There are a variety of laws and regulations across the country defining the dos and don’ts of criminal background checks. Research and outsourcing will ensure proactive approaches to criminal background checking.    
  • Policies & Procedures: With evolving legislation, make it a priority to updates any policies and procedures in relation to drug-free workplaces, preemployment testing, reasonable suspicion, post-accident testing, etc. Regardless of the laws and regulations, there should be  zero-tolerance policy in place any employee being under the influence or any drug or alcohol in the workplace. Implementing an Employee Assistance Program (EAP) is recommended for organizations large and small. Train supervisors on enforcing the policy and procedures and communicate any changes throughout the organization.” (Burr SHRM Article)

The Americans with Disabilities Act until recently, ruled against reasonable accommodation in relation to medicinal marijuana use.  Employer-Friendly decisions include Washburn v. Columbia Forest Products, Inc., Roe v. Teletch Customer Care Mgmt., Johnson vs. Columbia Falls Aluminum Co., and Ross v. RagingWire Telecommunications, Inc.  Three out of the four rulings for employers happened in pro-marijuana states: California, Oregon and Washington.  However, along comes Barbuto vs. Advantage Sales and Marketing, LLC; “the Massachusetts high court addressed whether an employer must accommodate medical cannabis use, since state law permits medical marijuana use and prohibits disability discrimination…The court held that an exception to the employer’s drug policy to permit offsite marijuana use may be a reasonable accommodation where the employee’s physician determines that marijuana is the most effective treatment for the employee’s disability and that any alternative medication permitted by the employer’s drug policy would be less effective.” https://www.shrm.org/resourcesandtools/legal-and-compliance/state-and-local-updates/pages/must-employers-accommodate-medical-marijuana.aspx

https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/third-circuit-rules-that-employees-2174704/

“Schedule I: Schedule I drugs, substances, or chemicals are defined as drugs with no currently accepted medical use and a high potential for abuse. Some examples of Schedule I drugs are: heroin, lysergic acid diethylamide (LSD), marijuana (cannabis), 3 methylenedioxymethamphetamine (ecstasy), methaqualone, and peyote”  “Despite marijuana’s Schedule I status, former President Barack Obama’s administration issued a memo in 2013 stating that federal prosecutors wouldn’t target adults who were growing or using marijuana in accordance with state laws. Instead, the federal government focused its efforts on preventing marijuana sales to minors and stopping drug cartels.  Although President Donald Trump’s administration rescinded the Obama-era memo, there hasn’t been a ramp up in enforcement, and states continue to approve marijuana use.” https://www.dea.gov/drug-scheduling

On August 29, 2023, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (“HHS”) recommended to the Drug Enforcement Administration (“DEA”) that marijuana be reclassified from a Schedule I controlled substance to a Schedule III controlled substance. Reclassification in this manner, should the DEA choose to follow this recommendation, could have profound implications on the marijuana industry, medical research, tax and banking, and criminal enforcement.

December 2024 YouTube DEA Marijuana Hearings

See attached DEA PDF

Medicinal Marijuana & Workers Compensation

On March 17, 2023, the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania issued a decision regarding employee use of medical marijuana in the workers’ compensation context.  The decision in Fegley v. Firestone Tire & Rubber (Workers’ Comp. Appeal Bd.) addresses an issue of first impression.  The court held that an employer’s failure to reimburse an employee’s out-of-pocket costs for medical marijuana to treat his work-related injury was a violation of the Pennsylvania Workers’ Compensation Act (“WC Act”).  The decision is significant for Pennsylvania employers.  Given this decision, Pennsylvania employers could be subject to penalties under the WC Act if they do not reimburse employees for medical marijuana use—even though marijuana is illegal under federal law and cannot be prescribed by any doctors.

CASE BACKGROUND

The employee in the underlying case sustained a work-related injury to his back.  After decades of taking prescribed opiates and narcotics, the employee began using medical marijuana at the recommendation of his doctor.  His pain level improved through use of marijuana, to the point that he was able to wean himself off of the prescription drugs.  An entity responsible for evaluating the appropriateness of treatment for work-related injuries under the state workers’ compensation system found that the employee’s medical marijuana use was reasonable and necessary.  However, the employer refused to reimburse the employee for the cost of his medical marijuana treatment.

The employee filed a claim seeking penalties for the employer’s alleged violation of the WC Act by failing to pay for the cost of his medical marijuana use.  The employer prevailed at the agency level on the grounds that the Pennsylvania Medical Marijuana Act (“MMA”) says that coverage is not required for medical marijuana and requiring an employer to fund marijuana use would violate federal law and did not violate the WC Act.  The employee then appealed to the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania.

DECISION ON APPEAL

In a 5-2 decision, the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania disagreed with the agency ruling below, and thus reversed and remanded.  In reaching its decision, the Court analyzed the contours of, and the relationship between, the WC Act, the MMA, and related federal law. 

Starting with the basics, the Court observed that the WC Act requires reimbursement to employees for reasonable and necessary medical expenses resulting from work-related injuries.  The Court also observed that the MMA deems marijuana to be a legitimate therapy for treatment of medical issues under proper circumstances.  And the MMA seeks to protect individuals who use medical marijuana by stating that medical marijuana patients shall not be “denied any right or privilege, . . . solely for lawful use of medical marijuana . . .” 

The MMA, however, also has a section entitled “Conflict”, which provides that “[n]othing in [the MMA] shall be construed to require an insurer or a health plan, whether paid for by Commonwealth funds or private funds, to provide coverage for medical marijuana.”  This did not end the Court’s inquiry.  The Court found that the absence of the word “reimbursement” in this Conflict provision is significant.  While a well-reasoned dissenting opinion described “coverage” and “reimbursement” as “two sides of the same coin”, the majority disagreed.  The Court held that “coverage” and “reimbursement” have materially distinct definitions.  The Court reasoned that the MMA does not require coverage for medical marijuana, but there is no language in the MMA precluding a WC carrier from reimbursing a claimant for medical expenses that are reasonable and necessary to treat a work-related injury.  In the Court’s view, employers must therefore reimburse employees for medical marijuana treatment that is reasonable and necessary for work-related injuries.  This conclusion, the Court noted, is consistent with the WC Act’s reimbursement requirement, along with the MMA’s endorsement of medical marijuana and corresponding prohibition against the denial of rights or privileges based solely on medical marijuana use.

The Court also addressed the relationship between state and federal law.  The MMA contains a provision stating that [n]othing in [the MMA] shall require an employer to commit any act that would put the employer or any person in violation of federal law.”  Under federal law, it is unlawful for “any person knowingly or intentionally – [] to manufacture, distribute, or dispense, or possess with intent to manufacture, distribute, or dispense, a controlled substance[.]” 21 U.S.C. § 841(a).  The Court did not find this to be a persuasive reason for reaching a different decision because reimbursement is not the same as manufacturing, distribution, or dispensing of marijuana.  Thus, reimbursement is not illegal.

In her dissent, Judge Christine Fizzano Cannon discussed the interplay between state and federal law.  She wrote that “[a]lthough the MMA legalizes the use of medical marijuana in Pennsylvania, a provider still cannot legally dispense medical marijuana under federal law” because it is illegal.  She reasoned that an illegal treatment cannot be reasonable or necessary under the WC Act and, in turn, an employer should not be responsible for reimbursement.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

This decision—unless it is overturned or superseded—has immediate impact on employers in Pennsylvania.  Indeed, they are now required to reimburse employees for medical marijuana treatment for work-related injuries under the WC Act.  Failure to do so could result in penalties.

This holding is consistent with holdings in New Mexico, New Jersey, New Hampshire, New York and Connecticut.  However, it is contrary to holdings in Massachusetts, Maine, and Minnesota.  (https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/pennsylvania-court-holds-that-it-is-2936018/

Drug Free Workplace Act

The most important piece of legislation regulating federal contractors and grantees is the Drug-free Workplace Act of 1988 (PDF | 204 KB). Under the act, a drug-free workplace policy is required for:

  • Any organization that receives a federal contract of $100,000 or more
  • Any organization receiving a federal grant of any size

At a minimum, such organizations must:

  • Prepare and distribute a formal drug-free workplace policy statement. This statement should clearly prohibit the manufacture, use, and distribution of controlled substances in the workplace and spell out the specific consequences of violating this policy.
  • Establish a drug-free awareness program. This program should inform employees of the dangers of workplace substance use; review the requirements of the organization’s drug-free workplace policy; and offer information about any counseling, rehabilitation, or employee assistance programs (EAPs) that may be available.
  • Ensure that all employees working on the federal contract understand their personal reporting obligations. Under the terms of the Drug-Free Workplace Act, an employee must notify the employer within five calendar days if he or she is convicted of a criminal drug violation.
  • Notify the federal contracting agency of any covered violation. Under the terms of the Drug-free Workplace Act, the employer has 10 days to report that a covered employee has been convicted of criminal drug violation.
  • Take direct action against an employee convicted of a workplace drug violation. This action may involve imposing a penalty or requiring the offender to participate in an appropriate rehabilitation or counseling program.
  • Maintain an ongoing good faith effort to meet all the requirements of the Drug-free Workplace Act throughout the life of the contract. Covered organizations must demonstrate their intentions and actions toward maintaining a drug-free workplace. Their failure to comply with terms of the Drug-Free Workplace Act may result in a variety of penalties, including suspension or termination of their grants/contracts and being prohibited from applying for future government funding.

OSH Act

Duty to provide employees with a workplace “free from recognized hazards that are causing or are likely to cause death or serious physical harm”

Substance abuse is such a hazard.

DOT “Medical Marijuana” Notice

DOT Office of Drug and Alcohol Policy and Compliance Notice

Recently, the Department of Justice (DOJ) issued guidelines for Federal prosecutors in states that have enacted laws authorizing the use of “medical marijuana.” http://www.justice.gov/opa/documents/medical-marijuana.pdf

We have had several inquiries about whether the DOJ advice to Federal prosecutors regarding pursuing criminal cases will have an impact upon the Department of Transportation’s longstanding regulation about the use of marijuana by safety‐sensitive transportation employees – pilots, school bus drivers, truck drivers, train engineers, subway operators, aircraft maintenance personnel, transit fire‐armed security personnel, ship captains, and pipeline emergency response personnel, among others.

We want to make it perfectly clear that the DOJ guidelines will have no bearing on the Department of Transportation’s regulated drug testing program. We will not change our regulated drug testing program based upon these guidelines to Federal prosecutors.

The Department of Transportation’s Drug and Alcohol Testing Regulation – 49 CFR Part 40, at 40.151(e) – does not authorize “medical marijuana” under a state law to be a valid medical explanation for a transportation employee’s positive drug test result.

That section states:

§ 40.151 What are MROs prohibited from doing as part of the verification process?
As an MRO, you are prohibited from doing the following as part of the verification process:
(e) You must not verify a test negative based on information that a physician recommended that the employee use a drug listed in Schedule I of the Controlled Substances Act. (e.g., under a state law that purports to authorize such recommendations, such as the “medical marijuana” laws that some states have adopted.)

Therefore, Medical Review Officers will not verify a drug test as negative based upon information that a physician recommended that the employee use “medical marijuana.” Please note that marijuana remains a drug listed in Schedule I of the Controlled Substances Act. It remains unacceptable for any safety‐sensitive employee subject to drug testing under the Department of Transportation’s drug testing regulations to use marijuana.

We want to assure the traveling public that our transportation system is the safest it can possibly be.

Jim L. Swart
Director
Office of the Secretary of Transportation
Office of Drug and Alcohol
Policy and Compliance
Department of Transportation
October 22, 2009

https://www.transportation.gov/odapc/medical-marijuana-notice

“Implications of Legalization of Recreational Marijuana

Despite three states—Arkansas, North Dakota and South Dakota—rejecting in 2022 the legalization of adult recreational marijuana use, three other states—Maryland, Missouri and Rhode Island—legalized such use.

“I think the legalization of marijuana is inevitable nationwide; it’s just a matter of how and when,” said Dillon McGuire, an attorney with Pashman Stein Walder Hayden in Holmdel, N.J.

Recreational marijuana is now legal in 21 states plus the District of Columbia.

Therapeutic Psychedelics

In the U.S., the use of certain psychedelics in a facilitated, supervised setting is lawful in Colorado and Oregon, noted Lauren Carboni, an attorney with Foley & Lardner in Denver, and John Litchfield, an attorney with Foley & Lardner in Chicago.

In November 2020, Oregon became the first state to regulate therapeutic psilocybin sessions for adults 21 and older in licensed, clinical settings.

Psilocybin is the psychoactive compound found in what is referred to as magic mushrooms, explained Christine Lamb, an attorney with Fortis Law Partners in Denver.

The state begins accepting applications for licensure of facilities to administer its regulated psilocybin services program on Jan. 2, 2023.

In November 2022, Colorado voters approved a similar measure. By Sept. 30, 2024, the Colorado Department of Regulatory Agencies must adopt implementation rules.” (SHRM)

Additional Resources:

https://www.shrm.org/resourcesandtools/pages/marijuana.aspx

Other Considerations:

  • Policy & Procedure Revisions
  • Review State & Local Legislation
  • Drug Free Workplace Act Considerations
  • Employee Assistance Program
  • DBL & FMLA 
  • ADA
  • Reasonable Suspicion Training for Supervisors
  • Communicate with the Workforce
  • DOT Regulations
  • Policy Signature

Frequently Asked Questions:

Question: Is there a federal requirement for businesses to put up a Drug-Free Workplace poster?

Answer:

No. There is no such federal requirement. Some businesses that receive contracts or grants from the federal government use posters to help fulfill some of the educational requirements under the Drug-Free Workplace Act of 1988.

https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/high-stakes-and-political-blazes-top-10-1961805/

Basis for Reasonable- Suspicion Testing

We, the following managers/supervisors/employees and representative or designee, concur with the need for reasonable-suspicion testing in accordance with Organization X current policy for the following employee:

        Name: ___________________________________    

        Work Area: _______________________________

        Location: _________________________________

We observed and/or been informed of the following: (Circle all that apply)

Unusual Physical Sign(s):Slurred SpeechStaggered gaitImbalanceBloodshot EyesConfusionDisorientationLack of LucidityOdor of AlcoholOther: ________________Unusual Behaviors(s):Sudden unexplained changes in behaviorsMood swingsEmotional/violent outburstsThreatsFrequent tardiness or absenteeismUnexplained whereaboutsA record of avoidable accidentsOther: ________________
Complaint(s) From:Customer or VendorVisitorEmployeeImmediate Supervisor or ManagerOther Credible Witness: _____________________What is the nature of the complaint and the dates/times of occurrence, if known: __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Additional Comments: _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Verifying Witnesses
 Name: __________________________________ Title: ___________________________________ Signature: _______________________________ Date: ___________________    Time: _________ AM/PM
 Name: __________________________________ Title: ___________________________________ Signature: _______________________________ Date: ___________________    Time: _________ AM/PM

https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/a-cautionary-tale-regarding-the-1520506/